# Contingent risk insurance: what it covers, costs and excludes

Contingent risk insurance transfers a known legal or regulatory exposure to insurers, typically one with a low chance of going wrong and a large loss if it does. The broker Vanbridge says premiums generally range from 8% to 20% rate-on-line, meaning premium as a share of the limit bought, and that policies are typically designed for exposures of at least $5 million [Vanbridge](https://www.vanbridge.com/solutions/alternatives-insurance-capital/transactional-risk/contingent-liability/). Terms are negotiated case by case, and we found no public index of prices.

By Rachel Brown, Paralegal. Last checked: November 18, 2026. Canonical page: https://lawsuitloancompanies.com/litigation-finance/insurance/contingent-risk-insurance/

Key points:
- Marsh says contingent risk insurance began in M&A deals and is now commonly bought as a stand-alone policy.
- Vanbridge puts premiums at 8% to 20% rate-on-line, usually as a one-time charge, for exposures of at least $5 million.
- Aon says its policies pay on final judgments only, exclude defense costs and settlements, and leave control of the case with the insured.
- Aon reports that 8.1% of the policies it has placed since 2014 produced a carrier loss, all on judgment preservation deals.

## What contingent risk insurance is

Marsh defines contingent risk insurance as cover that transfers the risk around known legal and regulatory exposures to insurers. It gives a litigant more certainty about the outcome of a pending or expected proceeding by setting a floor on recoveries for plaintiffs or a ceiling on exposure for defendants [Marsh](https://www.marsh.com/en/services/private-equity-mergers-acquisitions/expertise/contingent-liability-insurance.html).

The product grew out of deal-making. Marsh says it was first used in mergers and acquisitions to deal with known risks that could derail a transaction, and is now commonly used as a stand-alone solution [Marsh](https://www.marsh.com/en/services/private-equity-mergers-acquisitions/expertise/contingent-liability-insurance.html). Aon says the risks it suits are those capable of legal analysis, typically low in probability but high in severity [Aon](https://www.aon.com/apac/transaction-solutions/litigation-and-contingent-risks-insurance). It is one branch of [litigation insurance](https://lawsuitloancompanies.com/litigation-finance/litigation-insurance/).

## The main forms, with brokers' examples

Hypothetical use cases published by Marsh on its contingent liability insurance page. They are illustrations by the broker, not reported transactions.

| Form | Who it protects | Marsh's hypothetical |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Judgment preservation | A plaintiff with a judgment under appeal | $80 million judgment, $40 million policy, $20 million loan against it |
| Adverse judgment | A defendant or M&A target | $80 million antitrust suit, policy above a $10 million retention |
| Work-in-progress | A contingency-fee law firm | $20 million limit on three cases, responding after five years |
| Successor liability | A buyer of assets | Cover against claims inherited from a seller's pending arbitration |

Vanbridge adds two further uses: principal protection for capital that litigation funders have committed, and law firm portfolio insurance that gives certainty around future contingent fees [Vanbridge](https://www.vanbridge.com/solutions/alternatives-insurance-capital/transactional-risk/contingent-liability/). Compare [portfolio funding](https://lawsuitloancompanies.com/litigation-finance/portfolio-funding/) from a funder.

## What does contingent risk insurance cost?

Contingent risk insurance premiums generally range from 8% to 20% rate-on-line, according to the broker Vanbridge, usually as a one-time charge and sometimes with a deferred or contingent element [Vanbridge](https://www.vanbridge.com/solutions/alternatives-insurance-capital/transactional-risk/contingent-liability/). Aon likewise describes a one-time upfront premium [Aon JPI brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx). No regulator or trade body publishes pricing data.

An Aon managing director gave a worked example to Law360 that the ABA Journal reprinted in 2024: a plaintiff with a $15 million trial win might pay a premium of $1 million to $2 million for a $10 million judgment preservation policy, guaranteeing $8 million to $9 million net of premium if the judgment were wiped out [ABA Journal](https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/as-judgment-preservation-insurance-gains-steam-appellate-decision-leaves-insurers-on-hook-for-millions).

The premium does not have to come from cash on hand. Aon says the proceeds of a loan secured on the policy and the judgment can be used to pay it [Aon JPI brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx).

## How insurers set the retention and the limit

Underwriters ask two questions, Vanbridge says: how likely an adverse outcome is, and how large the loss would probably be [Vanbridge](https://www.vanbridge.com/solutions/alternatives-insurance-capital/transactional-risk/contingent-liability/). For defense-side cover, Aon says insurers want reliable information on the likely worst-case damages, and that figure typically becomes the attachment point for coverage [Aon brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/9e9f1c79-27e7-4b3f-b7cc-2b206ef0a3e1/Aon-Litigation-Risk-Insurance.aspx).

For a judgment under appeal the logic runs the other way. Aon gives this example: if insurers see a realistic chance that a $100 million judgment is cut by $25 million but think a deeper cut highly unlikely, they will offer $75 million of coverage above a $25 million deductible. The deductible keeps the insured exposed to part of the loss [Aon JPI brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx).

## What the policies leave out

Aon describes judgment preservation insurance as judgments-only coverage. It typically does not cover defense costs or settlement outcomes, and it does not let insurers take control of the litigation, so the insured keeps its chosen counsel and its decision-making power [Aon JPI brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx). The same limits apply to Aon's adverse judgment policies [Aon brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/9e9f1c79-27e7-4b3f-b7cc-2b206ef0a3e1/Aon-Litigation-Risk-Insurance.aspx).

Exclusions are few. Vanbridge says policies contain minimal exclusions, typically fraud by the insured and actions inconsistent with the insured position [Vanbridge](https://www.vanbridge.com/solutions/alternatives-insurance-capital/transactional-risk/contingent-liability/). Collection is a separate matter: Aon notes that borrowing against an insured judgment requires low collection risk, for example where the defendant has posted an appeal bond [Aon JPI brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx).

## How a policy gets placed

Aon sets out five phases for a judgment preservation placement [Aon JPI brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx).

- Insurability assessment: the broker's former litigators review the legal merits.
- Submission: a case overview and key documents, ideally with a memorandum from outside counsel.
- Preliminary underwriting: insurers ask questions and return non-binding quotes.
- Confirmatory diligence: the lead insurer typically brings in an outside law firm, and policy wording is drafted.
- Binding: the client pays the premium and coverage begins.

Not every case qualifies. Aon says adverse judgment cover suits litigation with a well-developed record, or early-stage cases where the facts are in the insured's hands or questions of law predominate [Aon brochure](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/9e9f1c79-27e7-4b3f-b7cc-2b206ef0a3e1/Aon-Litigation-Risk-Insurance.aspx).

## How have contingent risk policies performed?

Contingent risk policies tied to M&A deals have performed well for insurers, while single-case judgment preservation policies have produced the market's losses, according to Aon's claims studies. Across Aon's portfolio since 2014, 8.1% of policies placed resulted in a carrier paying a loss, each for the full limit, and every one was a judgment preservation deal [Aon Global Claims Study 2026](https://www.aon.com/insights/reports/2026-transaction-solutions-global-claims-study).

The best-known loss followed the April 2024 reversal of BMC Software's $1.6 billion judgment against IBM [ABA Journal](https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/as-judgment-preservation-insurance-gains-steam-appellate-decision-leaves-insurers-on-hook-for-millions). Aon wrote in 2025 that reported losses had reduced carrier appetite across the contingent risk market [Aon 2025 study](https://assets.aon.com/-/media/files/aon/reports/2025/2025-transaction-solutions-claims-study-north-america.pdf). Its 2026 study says the market now treats litigation risk insurance, where appetite has shrunk, separately from what it calls legal position insurance, which often involves no active lawsuit and is attracting more capacity [Aon Global Claims Study 2026](https://www.aon.com/insights/reports/2026-transaction-solutions-global-claims-study).

## Questions for your broker and counsel

The decision to insure a case belongs to the company and its advisers.

- Is the premium a single payment, or is part of it deferred or contingent on the result?
- What must happen before the policy pays, and how long could that take?
- How does the policy interact with any litigation funding agreement or contingency fee already in place?
- If the policy backs a loan, who is paid first from the judgment or the insurance proceeds?

## Sources

- [Vanbridge, Contingent Liability Insurance](https://www.vanbridge.com/solutions/alternatives-insurance-capital/transactional-risk/contingent-liability/): "Premiums generally range from 8-20% rate-on-line"
- [Marsh, Contingent Liability Insurance](https://www.marsh.com/en/services/private-equity-mergers-acquisitions/expertise/contingent-liability-insurance.html): "setting a floor on recoveries for plaintiffs or a ceiling on exposure for defendants"
- [Aon, Litigation and Contingent Risks Insurance](https://www.aon.com/apac/transaction-solutions/litigation-and-contingent-risks-insurance): "protects against the risk of having to pay the other side’s legal costs, the party’s own disbursements and part of their own legal fees"
- [Aon, Litigation Risk Insurance Solutions (brochure)](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/9e9f1c79-27e7-4b3f-b7cc-2b206ef0a3e1/Aon-Litigation-Risk-Insurance.aspx): "Litigation risk insurance is a strategic tool to help protect businesses from the risks of catastrophic judgments and preserve the benefits of favorable judgments."
- [Aon, Judgment Preservation Insurance: Protecting and Monetizing Court Judgments and Arbitration Awards (February 2022)](https://www.aon.com/getmedia/bd8aa935-d0ae-48c7-b00a-0cd46227d82c/Aon-s-Judgment-Preservation-Insurance-Solution-Feb-2022.pdf.aspx): "who between them have the market capacity to provide up to $1 billion in coverage"
- [Aon, Global Claims Study 2026](https://www.aon.com/insights/reports/2026-transaction-solutions-global-claims-study): "just 8.1% of policies placed have resulted in carriers paying a loss (each was a limit loss), with all of those instances occurring on JPI deals"
- [Aon, 2025 Transaction Solutions Global Claims Study: North America](https://assets.aon.com/-/media/files/aon/reports/2025/2025-transaction-solutions-claims-study-north-america.pdf): "These reported anticipated losses have led to a reduction in carrier appetite, not only in judgment preservation insurance, but also in the broader contingent risk market"
- [ABA Journal, As judgment preservation insurance gains steam, appellate decision leaves insurers 'on the hook' for millions (May 8, 2024)](https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/as-judgment-preservation-insurance-gains-steam-appellate-decision-leaves-insurers-on-hook-for-millions): "The insurance pays the insured a portion of a judgment if it is overturned on appeal."
