# Judgment preservation insurance and contingent risk cover

Judgment preservation insurance pays the holder of a money judgment if the award is reversed or reduced on appeal. It is the best known form of what the market calls contingent risk insurance, and it is now tied closely to litigation finance: Westfleet Advisors reports that about 21% of new US commercial funding commitments in its 2025 survey year were fully or partially insured, up from 19%.

By Rachel Brown, Paralegal. Last checked: November 18, 2026. Canonical page: https://lawsuitloancompanies.com/litigation-finance/insurance/judgment-preservation-insurance/

Key points:
- A 2024 American University Law Review article says judgment preservation insurance was unheard of as recently as 2017.
- Appian disclosed a $500 million policy on a $2.1 billion judgment, priced at 9.8% of the limit; the case was later sent back for retrial.
- The Court of Federal Claims ordered a law firm's policy on a $185 million class action fee award disclosed in January 2024.
- No regulator or rating agency has published loss data for this line of insurance that we could find.

## How the cover works

The party that won at trial buys a policy while the appeal is pending. If the final judgment comes in below an agreed figure, the insurer pays the difference up to the policy limit. The Government Accountability Office describes the product as protecting the plaintiff's financial interests if a favorable judgment is ultimately reversed or reduced on appeal. [GAO-25-107214](https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-25-107214.pdf)

An article in the ABA's Business Law Today adds that the cover can attach to summary judgment awards, trial verdicts and arbitration awards. [ABA Business Law Today](https://businesslawtoday.org/2024/03/risky-business-insuring-damage-awards-through-judgment-preservation-insurance/) In the one policy whose terms are public, Appian paid an aggregate premium of 9.8% of a $500 million limit to insure part of a $2.1 billion trade secret judgment against Pegasystems. [Stroud and Korte, 73 Am. U. L. Rev. 1057](https://aulawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Stroud-Korte.to_.Printer.pdf)

## What contingent risk insurance means

Contingent risk insurance is the industry's umbrella term for policies that pay on a legal outcome. Westfleet uses it for the insured share of funding deals without defining it, and we found no statute, regulator or court that defines the category. [Westfleet Insider 2025](https://www.westfleetadvisors.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Westfleet-Insider-2025.pdf) Judgment preservation insurance is the member of the family that has been described in court orders and law reviews, so this page concentrates on it.

The product is recent. Stroud and Korte write that it was unheard of as recently as 2017, and that a regulatory blind spot allows policies to stay concealed from courts through the appeal. [Article abstract](https://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/aulr/vol73/iss4/2)

## Who buys it and why

- **Judgment holders.** A company with a large award under appeal can lock in a floor. Appian's policy is the documented example.
- **Borrowers against judgments.** The law review article reports that the cover is often used together with litigation funding, because an insured judgment supports cheaper financing and lets the holder borrow against the policy.
- **Law firms.** A firm can insure a fee award. In Health Republic Insurance Co. v. United States, class counsel did not deny buying a policy covering an original $185 million fee award. [Health Republic order](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-cofc-1_16-cv-00259/pdf/USCOURTS-cofc-1_16-cv-00259-6.pdf)
- **Funders.** Westfleet's figures show about one fifth of new commitments carried insurance in 2025.

The appeal to a funder or lender is that the policy converts an uncertain legal claim into something closer to an insured receivable. No public data shows what share of insured deals involve judgment preservation cover as against other policy types.

## When judgments are reversed

The risk is real and it is concentrated. Appian's verdict was vacated on appeal, and the company announced on January 8, 2026 that the Supreme Court of Virginia had remanded the case for retrial. [Appian press release](https://appian.com/about/explore/press-releases/2026/appian-intellectual-property-suit-headed-to-retrial) No public source says what the insurers have paid.

In 2024 the Fifth Circuit reversed a judgment of more than $1.6 billion that BMC Software had won against IBM. [BMC Software v. IBM](https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/22/22-20463-CV0.pdf) The ABA Journal reported that insurers had guaranteed part of that award. [ABA Journal](https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/as-judgment-preservation-insurance-gains-steam-appellate-decision-leaves-insurers-on-hook-for-millions) The court's opinion does not mention insurance, and no loss figure has been published by an insurer or regulator.

We found no commentary on losses in this line from the NAIC, a state insurance department or a rating agency. Statements about loss ratios in broker reports cannot be checked against a public source.

## Do courts require disclosure of judgment preservation insurance?

No general rule requires disclosure of judgment preservation insurance, but a court has ordered it in a class action. In Health Republic Insurance Co. v. United States the Court of Federal Claims on January 30, 2024 granted discovery of the policy documents that class counsel was said to have bought on its fee award, citing transparency and its fiduciary duty in assessing class action fees. [Health Republic order](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-cofc-1_16-cv-00259/pdf/USCOURTS-cofc-1_16-cv-00259-6.pdf)

The ABA Business Law Today article warns that courts may compel disclosure and that a policy may shift some control of the litigation from the policyholder to the insurer. Stroud and Korte propose a disclosure requirement on appeal. We found no court rule adopting it.

## How it differs from ATE insurance and from funding

Comparison drawn from the GAO, Jackson report and law review descriptions cited on this page and on the ATE insurance page.

|  | Judgment preservation insurance | ATE insurance | Litigation funding |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| When it is bought | After a judgment, before appeal ends | After a dispute arises | Before or during the case |
| What it covers | Loss of the award on appeal | The opponent's legal costs | The cost of running the case |
| Who is paid | The judgment holder | The insured, for the opponent's costs | The claimant or law firm, up front |

The older product is described in [after-the-event insurance](https://lawsuitloancompanies.com/litigation-finance/insurance/ate-insurance/).

## Questions for a policyholder

- What triggers payment: reversal, reduction, a new trial, or settlement below the insured amount.
- What rights the insurer has over the appeal and over any settlement.
- Whether the policy must be disclosed to the court or the other side in this forum.
- What happens to the cover if the case is remanded for retrial.

Policy wordings are negotiated and not public. Coverage counsel should review them, and this page does not recommend buying or relying on any policy.

## Sources

- [Jonathan Stroud and Sam Korte, Insuring Judgments and the Disclosure Gap, 73 Am. U. L. Rev. 1057 (2024)](https://aulawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Stroud-Korte.to_.Printer.pdf): "JPI insures recovery of a monetary judgment pending appeal."
- [American University Law Review, vol. 73 iss. 4, article page](https://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/aulr/vol73/iss4/2): "a regulatory blind spot allows these policies to remain concealed from the courts throughout the appellate process"
- [US Government Accountability Office, Intellectual Property: Information on Third-Party Funding of Patent Litigation, GAO-25-107214 (Dec. 2024)](https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-25-107214.pdf): "helps protect the plaintiff’s financial interests if a favorable court judgment is ultimately reversed or reduced on appeal"
- [Risky Business: Insuring Damage Awards through Judgment Preservation Insurance, ABA Business Law Today (Mar. 2024)](https://businesslawtoday.org/2024/03/risky-business-insuring-damage-awards-through-judgment-preservation-insurance/): "JPI policies may also shift some control of the litigation from the policyholder to the insurer."
- [Health Republic Insurance Co. v. United States, No. 16-259 (Fed. Cl. Jan. 30, 2024) (GovInfo)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-cofc-1_16-cv-00259/pdf/USCOURTS-cofc-1_16-cv-00259-6.pdf): "in the interest of transparency and consistent with the Court’s fiduciary duty in assessing reasonable attorney’s fees in class actions"
- [Appian Corporation press release (Jan. 8, 2026)](https://appian.com/about/explore/press-releases/2026/appian-intellectual-property-suit-headed-to-retrial): "following the decision from the Supreme Court of Virginia remanding the case for retrial"
- [BMC Software, Inc. v. International Business Machines Corp., No. 22-20463 (5th Cir. 2024)](https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/22/22-20463-CV0.pdf): "appeals from a judgment awarding over $1.6 billion in contract and fraudulent"
- [ABA Journal, report on judgment preservation insurance and BMC v. IBM (May 8, 2024)](https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/as-judgment-preservation-insurance-gains-steam-appellate-decision-leaves-insurers-on-hook-for-millions): "The insurance pays the insured a portion of a judgment if it is overturned on appeal."
- [Westfleet Advisors, The Westfleet Insider: 2025 Litigation Finance Market Report](https://www.westfleetadvisors.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Westfleet-Insider-2025.pdf): "The use of contingent risk insurance remained a meaningful component of the market."
