What is a demand letter?

A demand letter is a written offer to settle your injury claim: it tells the at-fault party's insurer what happened, what you lost and how much you will accept. Some states regulate demands that carry a deadline. Georgia requires at least 30 days to accept a demand in a motor vehicle claim, and Missouri requires at least 90 days. Georgia SB 83 Missouri Revised Statutes 537.058

By , Paralegal· Checked ·4 min read ·6 sources

Key points

  • Missouri's statute lists what a time-limited demand must state, including the amount, the injuries and who will be released.
  • Georgia requires at least 30 days from receipt to accept a motor vehicle settlement demand prepared by an attorney.
  • In Florida, an insurer that tenders the policy limits or the amount demanded within 90 days of notice cannot be sued for bad faith.
  • Federal Rule of Evidence 408 bars using a settlement offer to prove that a disputed claim is valid or what it is worth.

What a demand letter contains

At its simplest, a demand tells the other side how much you say they owe you and why. California Courts Self-Help Guide Missouri's statute on time-limited demands gives a fuller picture. Such a demand must be in writing, be sent by certified mail to the liability insurer, and state:

  • how long the offer stays open
  • the amount of money requested, or a request for the policy limits
  • the date and location of the loss, and the claim number if known
  • a description of all known injuries
  • who will be released and which claims will be released

Missouri also requires a list of the health care providers who treated you, with signed authorizations so the insurer can obtain the records, and a list of your employers if you claim lost wages. Missouri Revised Statutes 537.058 Georgia requires the medical or other records in your side's possession that are sufficient to let the recipient evaluate the claim. Georgia SB 83

Time-limited demands and the state laws on them

A time-limited demand gives the insurer a deadline to accept. The deadline carries weight because state bad-faith laws can leave an insurer that wrongly fails to settle liable for more than its policy limit. Several legislatures have written rules for these demands.

StateMinimum timeWhat the law covers
Georgia 30 days from receipt to accept; a payment date at least 40 days from receiptOffers prepared by an attorney to settle a motor vehicle injury or death claim before the defendants answer a lawsuit. O.C.G.A. 9-11-67.1
Missouri 90 days from the insurer's receiptTime-limited demands to a liability insurer for personal injury, bodily injury or wrongful death. RSMo 537.058
Florida 90 days from actual notice of the claimAn insurer that tenders the policy limits or the amount demanded in that window, after receiving sufficient evidence, cannot be sued for bad faith. Fla. Stat. 624.155
State statutes on time-limited settlement demands. This is not a complete list of states.

In Missouri the insurer accepts by sending written acceptance of the material terms within the period the demand sets. Missouri Revised Statutes 537.058 Ask your attorney what your own state requires before a deadline is chosen.

Can a demand letter be used against me in court?

A demand letter generally cannot be used in federal court to prove that a claim is valid or what it is worth. Federal Rule of Evidence 408 bars evidence of offers to compromise a disputed claim, and of statements made during settlement talks, when offered for those purposes. Federal Rule of Evidence 408

The rule has exceptions. A court may admit the evidence for another purpose, such as proving a witness's bias. State courts apply their own evidence rules, so ask your attorney how your state treats settlement letters.

When a demand letter is sent

Timing is a judgment you make with your attorney. The amount you demand should cover future care, and that is hard to price until your doctor says your condition has stabilized. Our page on maximum medical improvement explains that milestone.

The other limit is the filing deadline. A statute of limitations is the time within which a lawsuit must be filed, so a demand letter on its own does not meet it. US Courts glossary Check the statute of limitations for your claim before negotiations run long.

The insurer can accept the demand, reject it or answer with a counteroffer. If talks fail, the next step is filing suit, and the personal injury lawsuit timeline shows what follows.

What to ask your attorney about a demand letter

  • Has my treatment reached the point where future costs can be estimated?
  • Does my state have a statute on time-limited demands, and will our letter follow it?
  • What are the at-fault party's policy limits, and are we demanding them?
  • How much time is left before the statute of limitations runs?

Sources

  1. California Courts Self-Help Guide Let them know how much they owe you and why you think they owe you the money.
  2. Missouri Revised Statutes 537.058 which shall not be less than ninety days from the date such demand is received by the liability insurer
  3. Georgia Senate Bill 83 (2024), amending O.C.G.A. 9-11-67.1 be not less than 30 days from receipt of the offer
  4. Florida Statutes 624.155 within 90 days after receiving actual notice of a claim which is accompanied by sufficient evidence to support the amount of the claim
  5. Federal Rule of Evidence 408 either to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim
  6. US Courts glossary The time within which a lawsuit must be filed or a criminal prosecution must begin.

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options