Key points
- Section 5891 defines a factoring transaction to include a sale, assignment, pledge or other encumbrance of payment rights.
- Florida's statute likewise defines a transfer to include a pledge or hypothecation made for consideration.
- You cannot ask the annuity company to pay early: section 130 bars the recipient from accelerating payments.
- The CFPB alleged that one buyer used cash advances to pressure sellers into completing transfers.
Why a pledge counts as a sale
A normal secured loan works by pledging an asset. If you stop paying, the lender takes the asset. Congress wrote the structured settlement rules so that this kind of pledge is covered by the same court review as an outright sale.
- Federal definition
- A factoring transaction is a transfer of payment rights for consideration by sale, assignment, pledge or other encumbrance.
made for consideration by means of sale, assignment, pledge, or other form of encumbrance or alienation for consideration
govinfo.gov - Florida definition
- A transfer means a sale, assignment, pledge, hypothecation or other alienation or encumbrance.
“Transfer” means a sale, assignment, pledge, hypothecation, or other form of alienation or encumbrance made by a payee for consideration.
leg.state.fl.us - Consequence
- Without a qualified court order, the acquirer owes tax of 40 percent of the factoring discount.
a tax equal to 40 percent of the factoring discount
govinfo.gov
Under Florida law, an unapproved transfer is also not effective, and the annuity issuer is not required to pay the transferee. Florida Statutes 626.99296 A lender who took a Florida payee's payments as collateral without a court order could not make the insurer redirect them.
Can you get your own payments early from the insurer?
A structured settlement recipient cannot draw payments early from the insurer. For the arrangement to qualify under section 130 of the tax code, the periodic payments "cannot be accelerated, deferred, increased, or decreased by the recipient". 26 U.S.C. 130
This is the trade made at settlement: the payments are tax-free and fixed. The only route to early cash from the payments themselves is a court-approved transfer to a third party, explained in selling structured settlement payments.
The narrow exception for banks
Section 5891 carves out one situation. A factoring transaction does not include the creation of a security interest in payment rights under a blanket security agreement with an insured depository institution, so long as nothing is done to redirect the payments to the bank or to enforce the interest against the payment rights. 26 U.S.C. 5891
In plain terms, a bank loan agreement that sweeps in all your assets does not by itself trigger the tax. The moment the bank tries to collect from the structured payments, the exception ends. Ask a bank whether it will count the payments as income when you apply for an ordinary loan, which is a different thing from pledging them.
Cash advances while a sale is pending
Some factoring companies offer a cash advance after you sign a sale agreement and before the court hearing. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau described this practice in its 2016 lawsuit against Access Funding. It alleged that the company told consumers the advances obligated them to go through with the sale, when the advances did not bind them to complete the transaction. CFPB
Those are allegations in one case. They are a reason to ask, before taking any advance, what happens to it if the judge denies the transfer or you change your mind. Illinois gives a payee the right to cancel a transfer agreement without penalty through the third business day after signing. 215 ILCS 153/10
What a court-approved deal must disclose
Whether the paperwork says "loan", "advance" or "purchase", a transfer that goes to court comes with a disclosure statement. In Florida and Illinois it must include the effective annual interest rate in a fixed sentence beginning "Based on the net amount that you will receive from us". Florida Statutes 626.99296 215 ILCS 153/10
Florida counts interest charges, discounts and "other compensation for the time value of money", along with application, origination, processing and similar fees, as part of the discount and finance charge. Florida Statutes 626.99296 No public dataset tracks the rates buyers charge. The only way to compare is to collect disclosure statements from more than one company.
Is selling part of your payments different from borrowing?
Selling part of a structured settlement is the closest lawful substitute for borrowing against it, and it goes through the same court process. Section 5891 covers transfers of payment rights "including portions of structured settlement payments". 26 U.S.C. 5891
A partial sale lets you transfer, say, a set number of monthly payments and keep the rest. The buyer collects those payments directly from the annuity issuer. You owe nothing afterward, and you also cannot get those payments back.
What to ask
- Is this a loan I repay, or a sale of specific payments? Ask to see the word "transfer" or "assignment" in the contract.
- Will the deal go before a judge? If not, ask the company why it believes section 5891 does not apply.
- What is the effective annual interest rate on the disclosure statement?
- If I take an advance before the hearing, must I repay it if the court says no?
- Could an ordinary personal loan that does not touch the payments meet the same need?
Your original settlement attorney can read the settlement agreement for restrictions on transfers. For how the payments are funded and protected, see structured settlement annuities.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. section 5891, Structured settlement factoring transactions
a tax equal to 40 percent of the factoring discount
- Florida Statutes section 626.99296, Transfers of structured settlement payment rights
The court has determined that the net amount payable to the payee is fair, just, and reasonable under the circumstances then existing.
- 26 U.S.C. section 130, Certain personal injury liability assignments
such periodic payments cannot be accelerated, deferred, increased, or decreased by the recipient of such payments
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, CFPB Sues Access Funding (Nov. 21, 2016)
typically represented only about 30 percent of the present value
- Illinois Structured Settlement Protection Act, 215 ILCS 153/10
not later than the third business day after the date the agreement is signed by the payee