Inheritance loans vs inheritance advances

An inheritance loan is money you must repay with interest. An inheritance advance is a sale: you assign a fixed part of your share of an estate, and the company is paid by the estate, not by you. Most products advertised as inheritance loans are advances, and a Yale Law Journal study found the companies offering them recovered their principal 96 percent of the time. Yale Law Journal

By , Paralegal· Checked ·5 min read ·7 sources

Key points

  • All five companies we reviewed say their product is an assignment, not a loan, and charge a fixed fee instead of interest.
  • California voids any contract term that lets an inheritance buyer collect from the heir personally if the estate falls short.
  • Usury laws govern only advances that are absolutely repayable, according to a Yale Law Journal study, which is why the label matters.
  • California exempts transactions made under its Financing Law from the assignment statute, so a licensed loan follows different rules.

The difference in one paragraph

With a loan, you owe the money. The lender charges interest for as long as the debt is open, and you remain liable if the thing you pledged turns out to be worth less than expected. With an advance, you sell a fixed dollar amount of your future inheritance for a smaller amount of cash today. The buyer waits for the estate to close and is paid from your share.

Three things change with the label: who bears the risk of a shortfall, whether the cost grows with time, and which consumer protection laws apply.

What the companies say they sell

Most companies in this market say they do not make loans. These are their own descriptions.

Inheritance Funding Company
Says an advance has no payments, collateral or interest. An advance is different from a loan because you don’t make payments, provide collateral or pay interest. inheritancefunding.com
Probate Advance
Says it is paid by the estate. This is not a loan, as we are paid directly out of the estate. probateadvance.com
Approved Inheritance Cash
Calls the contract an assignment. Since this Assignment is not a loan, no interest payments are ever due. approvedinheritancecash.com
InheritNOW
Calls it a sale and assignment. you assign, sell, and transfer a portion of your inheritance to us inheritnow.com

The published terms of each company are on our inheritance advance comparison page.

How California law draws the line

California Probate Code section 11604.5 governs a "transferee for value", meaning a business that regularly buys interests in estates under a written agreement. The statute treats the deal as a purchase and regulates it through court filing and disclosure. California Legislative Information

The same section says it does not apply to a transaction made under the California Financing Law and regulated by the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation. In other words, a licensed lender making a true loan to an heir is under the state's lending rules, and a buyer of inheritance rights is under the probate statute. California Legislative Information

Who is covered
A business that regularly buys estate interests for consideration. The person, directly or indirectly, regularly engages in the purchase of beneficial interests in estates for consideration. leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
Licensed loans excluded
Transactions under the California Financing Law are outside the section. A transaction made in conformity with the California Financing Law leginfo.legislature.ca.gov

Why the label matters

Two bodies of law depend on whether a deal is a loan. State usury statutes cap interest rates, and the federal Truth in Lending Act requires standard cost disclosures such as an annual percentage rate. The Yale study explains that usury laws govern only advances that are "absolutely repayable", and that most courts have exempted lawsuit funding from usury rules because the funder can lose its money. Yale Law Journal

The study reports that in the one case it found on probate advances, Reed v. Val-Chris Investments, a federal court held that the Truth in Lending Act did not reach an assignment of inheritance rights because the advance was non-recourse. The authors disagree with that result. In their data the companies recovered their principal 96 percent of the time, and they argue that a deal with so little risk is a loan in substance. Yale Law Journal

That is an academic argument, not settled law. For you, the practical effect is that an advance contract may not show an annual percentage rate, so you have to work out the yearly cost from the cash paid, the amount assigned and the expected wait.

Do you have to repay an inheritance advance if the estate comes up short?

An inheritance advance covered by California Probate Code section 11604.5 cannot be collected from the heir personally when the estate pays less than the amount assigned. The statute voids any contract term giving the buyer recourse against the beneficiary, except for expense or damage caused by the beneficiary's fraud or material breach of the agreement. California Legislative Information

Company policies say the same. Inheritance Funding Company states that if the estate lacks the assets to cover the assignment, it "simply takes the loss", unless the heir knew of a claim and failed to disclose it. Inheritance Funding Company Outside California, the answer depends on the contract, so ask for the recourse clause in writing.

Does an inheritance advance involve a credit check?

An inheritance advance is approved on the estate, not on your credit score, according to every company we reviewed, but a credit report may still be pulled. Inheritance Funding Company says it may obtain a credit report to look for judgments, child support or bankruptcy proceedings that could affect payment of the assignment. Inheritance Funding Company

Approved Inheritance Cash states that credit score, employment and income "are not factors". Approved Inheritance Cash If a credit inquiry matters to you, ask before you apply whether the company will pull a report and what kind.

What to ask an attorney

  • Is this contract a sale of part of my inheritance or a loan under my state's law?
  • Does my state require the agreement to be filed with the probate court?
  • Can the company collect from me personally for any reason other than fraud?
  • What is the yearly cost if the estate closes in 6 months, 12 months and 24 months?
  • Would the personal representative agree to a partial distribution instead?

Our guide to probate loans and probate advances covers the California filing rules and the cost evidence in more detail.

Sources

  1. Horton and Chandrasekher, Probate Lending, 126 Yale Law Journal (2016) the mean markup on the principal was a whopping sixty-nine percent per year
  2. Inheritance Funding Company, Inheritance Advance FAQ The cost involved with an advance is dependent on a number of specific factors
  3. Probate Advance, How It Works This is not a loan, as we are paid directly out of the estate.
  4. Approved Inheritance Cash, How It Works Since this Assignment is not a loan, no interest payments are ever due.
  5. InheritNOW, FAQ The fees are calculated as a percentage of the total advance amount
  6. California Probate Code section 11604.5 The fees, charges, or consideration paid or agreed to be paid by the beneficiary were grossly unreasonable.
  7. Approved Inheritance Cash, FAQ Credit score, employment, and income are not factors.

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options