Key points
- Patent litigation represented 19 percent of litigation funding commitments in 2023, per Westfleet Advisors data cited by GAO.
- Four large technology companies told GAO that 50 to 75 percent of recent patent suits against them involved third-party funding.
- In funding agreements GAO reviewed, funders recouped principal first and often took a further one to three times their investment.
- Hearings under a Delaware standing order showed one plaintiff LLC kept only five percent of its patent revenue.
How much patent litigation is funded
No one knows precisely, because most courts do not require disclosure of funding arrangements GAO-25-107214. GAO's 2024 report collected the available estimates. Westfleet Advisors found patent litigation represented 19 percent of all funding commitments in 2023, and Unified Patents estimated that about 30 percent of patent lawsuits filed in 2022 were funded by third parties GAO-25-107214.
Defendants see more. Of seven large technology companies GAO interviewed, four estimated that between 50 and 75 percent of recent lawsuits against them involved third-party funding GAO-25-107214. GAO itself reviewed 12 cases suspected of being funded and found it difficult to confirm funding from public information GAO-25-107214.
Why patent cases need outside capital
Patent infringement lawsuits can cost millions of dollars GAO-25-107214. One judge told GAO that many subject matter experts charge $850 an hour and can spend hundreds of hours on a typical case. One funder said cases typically take 3 to 4 years to reach trial and that 30 percent of successful cases lose on appeal GAO-25-107214.
The contingency alternative has narrowed. University officials and inventors told GAO that fewer law firms are taking cases under a contingency fee arrangement because of the unique costs and risks of patent litigation GAO-25-107214. Funding fills part of that gap, sometimes by financing the law firm directly so that it can offer a contingency fee GAO-25-107214.
What funders look for in a patent case
Funders told GAO they look for strong patents that are not likely to be invalidated during the litigation, infringement tied to a valuable feature of a product, and a strong invention story GAO-25-107214.
Breadth helps. Burford Capital asks at the screening stage whether claims from multiple patents are being asserted, and lists among its criteria that the case is not a single patent case Burford Capital, diligence process. Burford also says patent matters typically require a longer diligence process than other commercial cases Burford Capital, Introduction to legal finance.
What it costs
GAO reviewed nine patent funding agreements. They were generally structured as a waterfall: the funder recoups its principal first, then often receives a multiple of its investment, typically one to three times, and a percentage of the remaining proceeds may be divided among the funder, the patent owner and the law firm GAO-25-107214.
Timing moves the split. In one agreement GAO reviewed, the patent owner received a larger percentage of remaining proceeds for settling before the first scheduled claim construction hearing GAO-25-107214. Officials from one university told GAO that expected settlements must typically be very high, in the hundreds of millions of dollars, for a third-party funder to make sense GAO-25-107214. A worked example of a waterfall is in what litigation funding costs.
What Delaware's disclosure orders revealed
In April 2022, Chief Judge Colm Connolly of the District of Delaware issued two standing orders. One requires a party that has non-recourse third-party funding to identify the funder, say whether its approval is necessary for litigation or settlement decisions, and briefly describe its financial interest. The other requires LLC and partnership parties to name every owner up the chain In re Nimitz Technologies, Fed. Cir..
The judge then held evidentiary hearings to test whether plaintiff LLCs in a group of patent cases had complied Nimitz v. CNET, D. Del. 2023. The Federal Circuit refused to stop the inquiry, denying a mandamus petition on December 8, 2022 In re Nimitz Technologies, Fed. Cir..
The November 27, 2023 opinion that followed set out what the hearings and documents showed. The owner of one plaintiff, Nimitz Technologies, testified that he believed Nimitz received ten percent of recoveries from asserting its patents. Another plaintiff, Mellaconic IP, received only five percent of its patent revenue, with an entity called Mavexar contractually entitled to 95 percent. Mellaconic's name was on 44 patent cases Nimitz v. CNET, D. Del. 2023.
The court referred the plaintiffs' attorneys to disciplinary counsel and referred the matters to the Department of Justice and the Patent and Trademark Office Nimitz v. CNET, D. Del. 2023. These plaintiffs worked with a patent monetization firm under consulting agreements, which is a different model from a funder financing an operating company's own patents. The episode is the fullest public record of who is paid in one corner of the market.
Who controls a funded patent case
Funders and law firms told GAO that plaintiffs retain control over the litigation, including when to settle. Funding agreements GAO reviewed nonetheless may require plaintiffs to consult the funder before accepting a settlement offer GAO-25-107214.
Influence can exist without a veto. One mediator told GAO that despite patent owners having control over settlement decisions, it was clear that the funders also had influence that sometimes complicated the discussions GAO-25-107214. The wider question is covered in who controls a funded case.
Do patent plaintiffs have to disclose litigation funding?
Patent plaintiffs have to disclose litigation funding only in courts that require it, and most do not. GAO's 2024 report found that most courts do not require disclosure of funding arrangements, while the District of New Jersey and one judge in the District of Delaware require parties to identify third-party funders GAO-25-107214.
In New Jersey the statement is due within 30 days of filing an initial pleading or transfer of the matter to the district D.N.J. Local Civil Rule 7.1.1. Before filing, a funded patent owner should ask counsel to check the local rules and the assigned judge's standing orders.
Sources
- U.S. Government Accountability Office, Intellectual Property: Information on Third-Party Funding of Patent Litigation (GAO-25-107214)
two to three times their investment before the patent owner begins receiving
- Burford Capital, Getting to yes: What lawyers need to know about Burford's litigation finance diligence process
Cases where the client must give up most of its upside in return for funding are not a good fit for Burford.
- Burford Capital, Introduction to legal finance
Burford’s minimum financing threshold is about $5 million needed by the client.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, In re Nimitz Technologies LLC, No. 2023-103 (Dec. 8, 2022)
approval is necessary for litigation or settlement decisions
- U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware, Nimitz Technologies LLC v. CNET Media, Inc., Memorandum Opinion (Nov. 27, 2023)
contractually entitled to 95% of the profits generated from licensing or litigating
- U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, Local Civil Rule 7.1.1
Within 30 days of filing an initial pleading or transfer of the matter to this district