Key points
- Plaintiffs sought punitive damages in 12% of state tort and contract trials in 2005 and received them in 5% of the trials they won.
- The Supreme Court has said few awards exceeding a single-digit ratio of punitive to compensatory damages will satisfy due process.
- State caps differ: Virginia limits punitive damages to $350,000, and Florida to the greater of three times compensatory damages or $500,000.
- The IRS treats punitive damages as taxable income even when they come with a settlement for physical injury.
When punitive damages are awarded
Ordinary carelessness is not enough. In Florida a defendant is liable for punitive damages only if clear and convincing evidence shows intentional misconduct or gross negligence. Florida Statutes 768.72 Texas allows them only when the claimant proves by clear and convincing evidence that the harm resulted from fraud, malice or gross negligence. Texas CPRC 41.003
Awards are uncommon. Punitive damages were sought in 12% of the roughly 25,000 tort and contract trials concluded in state courts in 2005. Among plaintiffs who won and had asked for them, 30% received them. Bureau of Justice Statistics Those figures cover trials only and date from 2005.
How large can a punitive damages award be?
The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the Constitution limits punitive damages, and that few awards exceeding a single-digit ratio between punitive and compensatory damages will satisfy due process. The Court set that marker in State Farm v. Campbell in 2003, where it found a $145 million punitive award on $1 million of compensatory damages excessive. State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. 408 (2003)
Courts review an award against three guideposts from BMW v. Gore: how reprehensible the conduct was, the disparity between the harm and the punitive award, and the civil penalties for comparable misconduct. In that case the Court found a $2 million punitive award grossly excessive against $4,000 in actual damages, a ratio of 500 to 1. BMW of North America v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559 (1996)
The ratio is not a fixed formula. State Farm adds that when compensatory damages are substantial, a lesser ratio, perhaps only equal to compensatory damages, can reach the outer limit of due process. State Farm v. Campbell
State caps on punitive damages
Some states add their own limits by statute. The table gives six examples; it is not a complete list, and each statute has exceptions, such as Wisconsin's for drunk driving.
| State | Cap on punitive damages | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Florida | The greater of three times compensatory damages or $500,000, with higher limits for some conduct | Fla. Stat. 768.73 |
| Texas | The greater of $200,000, or two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000 | Tex. CPRC 41.008 |
| Virginia | $350,000 in total | Va. Code 8.01-38.1 |
| Idaho | The greater of $250,000 or three times compensatory damages | Idaho Code 6-1604 |
| Montana | The lesser of $10 million or 3% of the defendant's net worth | Mont. Code 27-1-220 |
| Wisconsin | The greater of twice compensatory damages or $200,000 | Wis. Stat. 895.043 |
Are punitive damages taxable?
Yes. The IRS says punitive damages are taxable and are reported as other income, even if they were received in a settlement for personal physical injuries or physical sickness. IRS Publication 4345 The tax code's exclusion for physical injury damages expressly leaves out punitive damages. 26 U.S.C. 104
That makes the split between compensatory and punitive amounts in a verdict or settlement matter for your taxes. Our page on whether settlements are taxable covers the other categories. Ask a tax professional about your own return.
What punitive damages mean for a pending claim
The trial data above suggest punitive damages figure in a small share of cases. They come into play when the evidence shows something worse than negligence, and then only if a jury awards them and the award survives the caps and court review described above. Our page on compensatory damages covers the part of a claim that pays for your losses.
- Ask your attorney whether the facts of your case meet your state's standard for punitive damages.
- Ask whether your state caps them and whether any exception applies.
- Ask how a settlement would be allocated between compensatory and punitive amounts.
Sources
- US Courts glossary
Damages may be compensatory (for loss or injury) or punitive (to punish and deter future misconduct).
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Punitive Damage Awards in State Courts, 2005
Punitive damages were awarded in 700 (5%) of the 14,359 trials where the plaintiff prevailed.
- State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. 408 (2003)
few awards exceeding a single-digit ratio between punitive and compensatory damages, to a significant degree, will satisfy due process
- BMW of North America v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559 (1996)
the degree of reprehensibility of the nondisclosure; the disparity between the harm or potential harm suffered by Dr. Gore and his punitive damages award
- IRS Publication 4345
Punitive damages are taxable and should be reported as “Other Income” on line 8z of Form 1040
- 26 U.S.C. 104
the amount of any damages (other than punitive damages) received
- Florida Statutes 768.72
based on clear and convincing evidence, finds that the defendant was personally guilty of intentional misconduct or gross negligence
- Florida Statutes 768.73
an award of punitive damages may not exceed the greater of
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 41
an amount equal to any noneconomic damages found by the jury, not to exceed $750,000
- Virginia Code 8.01-38.1
In no event shall the total amount awarded for punitive damages exceed $350,000.
- Idaho Code 6-1604
No judgment for punitive damages shall exceed the greater of two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000)
- Montana Code 27-1-220
An award for punitive damages may not exceed $10 million or 3% of a defendant's net worth, whichever is less.
- Wisconsin Statutes 895.043
may not exceed twice the amount of any compensatory damages recovered by the plaintiff or $200,000, whichever is greater