Key points
- The calculator multiplies only medical costs, past and future, by the multiplier you choose; lost wages are added once.
- We found no statute, jury instruction or peer-reviewed study that supports a multiplier range of 1.5 to 5.
- Maryland caps non-economic damages in personal injury cases at a base of $500,000 that rises by $15,000 every October 1.
- Minnesota allows recovery only if your fault was not greater than the fault of the person you are claiming against.
The arithmetic
The calculator works in three steps, and each one uses only the numbers you enter.
- Economic damages: medical bills to date, plus expected future medical costs, plus lost wages.
- Non-economic damages: medical bills to date plus future medical costs, times your multiplier.
- Total: economic plus non-economic damages, times one minus your fault share.
A person who enters 25 percent fault sees the total cut by a quarter. Nothing else is adjusted.
Is the pain and suffering multiplier a legal rule?
The pain and suffering multiplier is not a legal rule. It is a shortcut used in settlement talks, and no statute or jury instruction tells anyone to use it. A 2006 law review article described the law as it stands: jurors are given vague instructions to reasonably compensate the plaintiff for non-economic losses. Northwestern University Law Review
That same article proposed giving juries nonbinding multipliers tied to medical costs. It was a proposal for reform, which shows that multipliers are not part of current law. Northwestern University Law Review
The clearest description of the practice we found comes from RAND research on auto injury claims, which says general damages are usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses. RAND Institute for Civil Justice That study covered car crashes, not falls, dog bites or medical errors. No authoritative source gives a range of multiples for any type of injury, and the 1.5 to 5 range here has none behind it.
Fault rules the calculator simplifies
The calculator reduces your total by your fault percentage and stops there. Washington's statute works that way: fault reduces the award in proportion and does not bar recovery. RCW 4.22.005
Other states add a cutoff. Minnesota allows recovery only if your fault was not greater than the other side's. Minnesota Statutes 604.01 Florida bars recovery in most negligence cases for anyone more than 50 percent at fault. Florida Statutes 768.81 Past those lines the true figure is zero, whatever the calculator shows. See comparative negligence for the versions.
Caps the calculator ignores
Some states limit non-economic damages by statute, and the calculator applies no cap. Two examples show how different the limits are.
- Maryland
- Non-economic damages in personal injury actions may not exceed $500,000 for claims arising on or after October 1, 1994, and the limit rises by $15,000 each October 1.
an award for noneconomic damages may not exceed $500,000
mgaleg.maryland.gov - Idaho
- A judgment for non-economic damages may not exceed $250,000 per claimant, a figure adjusted every July 1 since 2004 in line with the state's average wage.
exceeding the maximum amount of two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000)
legislature.idaho.gov
A cap binds a court judgment. In a settlement it shapes what the other side expects to face at trial. Ask your attorney whether your state has a cap and what the current dollar figure is.
What the result leaves out
The total is a gross figure. It does not subtract attorney fees, case costs or liens, which the what you keep calculator handles. It does not know how much insurance is available, whether the other side disputes your treatment, or how strong the evidence of fault is.
The guide to what a case is worth covers the public data on awards. Bring your own numbers to your attorney and ask which of them the insurer is likely to contest.
Sources
- North Carolina Pattern Jury Instructions, Civil 810.08, Personal Injury Damages: Pain and Suffering (UNC School of Government)
There is no fixed formula for placing a value on physical pain and mental suffering.
- Avraham, Putting a Price on Pain-and-Suffering Damages, 100 Northwestern University Law Review 87 (2006)
a system of age-adjusted multipliers would be assigned to plaintiffs’ medical costs
- RAND Institute for Civil Justice, How Big Is the Price Tag for Excess Auto Injury Claims? (research brief RB-9023-1)
The availability of general damages and the fact that they are usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses
- Revised Code of Washington 4.22.005, Effect of contributory fault
any contributory fault chargeable to the claimant diminishes proportionately the amount awarded as compensatory damages
- Minnesota Statutes section 604.01, Comparative fault; effect
if the contributory fault was not greater than the fault of the person against whom recovery is sought
- Florida Statutes section 768.81, Comparative fault
any party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages
- Maryland Code, Courts and Judicial Proceedings, section 11-108
an award for noneconomic damages may not exceed $500,000
- Idaho Code section 6-1603, Limitation on noneconomic damages
exceeding the maximum amount of two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000)