Key points
- Economic and non-economic damages made up about 90% of the money awarded to winning tort plaintiffs in 2005, split almost evenly between the two.
- The median trial award was $15,000 in motor vehicle cases and $400,000 in medical malpractice cases in 2005.
- In Florida, a person found more than 50% at fault for their own harm recovers nothing in most negligence cases.
- No public dataset records private settlements, so every published average is a partial view.
The three kinds of damages
Courts sort the money in an injury case into three groups. The Bureau of Justice Statistics describes them this way: economic damages cover actual financial losses such as medical costs, lost wages, lost future earnings and property damage. Non-economic damages cover pain and suffering, emotional distress and loss of consortium. Punitive damages are awarded to punish and deter the defendant. BJS tort report BJS full report
In tort trials won by plaintiffs in 2005, economic and non-economic damages together made up about 90% of the total awarded, divided almost evenly at 47% and 44%. Punitive damages were sought in only 9% of those trials. BJS tort report
Economic damages are the part you can document. Bills, pay records and repair estimates establish them. Non-economic damages have no receipt, which is one reason two similar injuries can resolve for different amounts.
What reduces the number
The total of your losses is a starting point. Four things commonly sit between that figure and what is paid.
- Your share of fault. State law can reduce damages when the injured person was partly to blame. In Florida, fault assigned to the claimant diminishes the award proportionately, and a person found more than 50% at fault for their own harm may not recover any damages in most negligence cases. Florida Statutes 768.81
- Legal caps. Some states limit certain damages in certain cases. California caps non-economic damages in medical malpractice claims that do not involve a death at $350,000 for cases filed from January 1, 2023, rising by $40,000 each January for 10 years to $750,000. California Civil Code 3333.2
- Insurance limits. Liability coverage has a dollar limit, and that is the most the insurer will pay even if the loss is larger. Texas Department of Insurance
- Repayment claims. Money that Medicare paid for your care must be repaid when a settlement, judgment or award is made. CMS
Each of these rules varies by state. Your attorney can tell you which apply.
What data exists
Several public sources report money paid in injury cases. Each measures something narrower than "what cases are worth."
| Source | What it measures | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| ISO via Triple-I | Average auto bodily injury liability claim, 2024 | $28,278 |
| BJS trial survey | Median award, motor vehicle trials, 2005 | $15,000 |
| BJS trial survey | Median award, medical malpractice trials, 2005 | $400,000 |
| JAMA Internal Medicine | Mean malpractice payment for physicians, 1992 to 2014 | $329,565 |
| Oregon DCBS | Average workers' comp claim disposition agreement, 2024 | About $30,250 |
The figures come from the Insurance Information Institute, the Bureau of Justice Statistics civil trial report and its tort trial report, a study in JAMA Internal Medicine and Oregon's settlement data. Separate pages cover the average car accident settlement, the average medical malpractice payout and the average workers' comp settlement.
What data does not exist
No public dataset records private settlements. A settlement is a contract between the parties, and it is generally not filed with a court or reported to an agency. Trial records are public, but bench and jury trials accounted for an estimated 4% of tort dispositions in 2005. Bureau of Justice Statistics
The exceptions are narrow. The National Practitioner Data Bank, a federal repository, collects reports of medical malpractice payments. NPDB Data Analysis Tool A few state agencies publish totals for claims they supervise, as Oregon does for workers' compensation. Oregon DCBS For an ordinary car crash or fall, nothing comparable exists.
Online settlement calculators cannot fill that gap. No public source validates the formulas they use.
How is pain and suffering calculated?
Pain and suffering has no fixed formula in the public data. The Bureau of Justice Statistics classifies pain and suffering as non-economic damages, and in tort trials won by plaintiffs in 2005, non-economic damages made up 44% of the money awarded, according to the BJS tort report. Judges and juries set those amounts case by case.
Outside a courtroom, the figure is negotiated, and no public dataset records the results. Ask your attorney how non-economic damages are argued in your state and whether a cap applies.
What you take home
The settlement figure is not the amount you receive. Under the ABA's model rule, a contingent fee agreement must be in writing and must state the lawyer's percentage, the expenses to be deducted, and whether expenses come out before or after the fee is calculated. At the end of the case the lawyer must give you a written statement showing the outcome and how your share was determined. ABA Model Rule 1.5
Liens and any pre-settlement funding are also paid from the recovery. In the largest study of consumer legal funding, the median client received $2,250 and paid back $3,380. Cornell Law Review Ask for an estimate of your net recovery, not just the gross figure, before you decide anything.
Questions to ask your attorney
- What are my documented economic damages so far, and what future costs can we prove?
- Could I be assigned a share of fault, and what does that do in this state?
- What are the limits of every insurance policy that might pay?
- After fees, costs and liens, what would I receive from a settlement at the figure being discussed?
The decision to settle belongs to you. The page on first settlement offers explains the rules.
Sources
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Civil Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005
Among all plaintiff winners, the median final award was $28,000.
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (full report text)
trials ($400,000) were 17 times greater than the overall
- Florida Statutes section 768.81, Comparative fault
any party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages
- California Civil Code section 3333.2 (California Legislative Information)
shall not exceed three hundred fifty thousand dollars ($350,000)
- Texas Department of Insurance, Auto insurance guide
Before you sign the release, talk to your doctor about any future medical treatment you might need.
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Medicare Secondary Payer
A conditional payment is a payment Medicare makes for services another payer may be responsible for.
- Insurance Information Institute, Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (ISO data)
the average auto liability claim for bodily injury was $28,278
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Civil Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (full report text)
motor vehicle accident cases was $15,000
- Schaffer et al., Rates and Characteristics of Paid Malpractice Claims Among US Physicians by Specialty, 1992-2014, JAMA Internal Medicine (2017)
the rate of paid claims decreased by 55.7%
- Oregon Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' compensation settlements dataset (data.oregon.gov)
"cdas_approved":"2920","cda_amount_thousands_":"88337"
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005
Together, bench and jury trials accounted for an estimated 4% of all tort dispositions in 2005.
- Health Resources and Services Administration, National Practitioner Data Bank, Data Analysis Tool
The National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) routinely collects information relating to medical malpractice payments
- Oregon Department of Consumer and Business Services, Workers' Compensation Board disputes: Settlements
CDAs are agreements between insurers and workers in which workers release their rights to claim benefits other than medical services.
- American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5: Fees
A contingent fee agreement shall be in a writing signed by the client and shall state the method by which the fee is to be determined
- Avraham and Sebok, An Empirical Investigation of Third Party Consumer Litigant Funding, 104 Cornell L. Rev. 1133 (2019)
An Empirical Investigation of Third Party Consumer Litigant Funding