Key points
- Section 104(a)(2) excludes physical injury damages from income whether paid as a lump sum or as periodic payments.
- The IRS says most interest you receive is taxable in the year it becomes available to you.
- Under section 130, a recipient cannot accelerate, defer, increase or decrease structured payments.
- Reversing a structure later means a court-approved sale at a discount.
The choice is made before you settle
A structured settlement is part of the settlement agreement itself. It is negotiated between you and the defendant, often with a structured settlement consultant or broker pricing the options. NSSTA Once the release is signed and the annuity is bought, the form of payment is locked in.
It is also not all or nothing. The trade association for the industry describes the consultant's job as determining "the proper amount of their settlement to place into a structured settlement", which leaves room for taking part of the money in cash and structuring the rest. NSSTA
How each one is taxed
The damages themselves are treated alike. Section 104(a)(2) excludes from gross income the amount of any damages, other than punitive damages, received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness, in either form. 26 U.S.C. 104
The gap opens with investment earnings. If you take a lump sum and put it in a bank account, certificates of deposit or bonds, the IRS says most interest you receive is taxable income in the year it becomes available to you. IRS With a structure, the growth is built into the payment schedule, and the trade association states that Congress provided that "100 percent of every structured settlement payment would be exempt from federal and state income taxes". NSSTA
That comparison holds for physical injury cases. Settlements for other claims may be taxable in whole or part. IRS Ask a tax professional how your own settlement is classified before relying on either treatment.
Control: what you can and cannot change
- Lump sum. The money is yours on day one. You can pay debts, buy a home, invest or spend it. Nothing in the tax code limits what you do with it.
- Structured settlement. The schedule is fixed. Section 130 requires that payments cannot be accelerated, deferred, increased or decreased by the recipient.
The source for the second point is the statute itself. 26 U.S.C. 130 Flexibility exists only at the design stage, when payments can be set to run for a period of years or for life, to start later, or to include future lump sums timed to known expenses. NSSTA
What does it cost to undo a structured settlement?
Undoing a structured settlement means selling future payments to a factoring company at a discount, with a judge's approval. Federal law taxes the buyer 40 percent of the discount if no court approves the sale in advance. 26 U.S.C. 5891
The discount is the cost, and it can be steep. In a 2016 enforcement action, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau alleged that one buyer paid lump sums of about 30 percent of the present value of the payments it took. CFPB No public dataset tracks typical discounts. The process is described in selling structured settlement payments.
Who holds the risk
With a lump sum, you carry the investment risk and the risk of spending the money too fast. Advocates for structures stress this point: the trade association says a structure provides a planned, dependable cash flow without market volatility. NSSTA
With a structure, you rely on the life insurance company that issued the annuity. If that company fails, state guaranty associations cover structured settlement annuities, in most states up to $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits for each payee. NOLHGA A structure with a present value above the limit is only partly covered. See structured settlement annuities for how that works.
Numbers you are entitled to see in some states
Comparing the two requires knowing what the structure costs the defendant. Florida requires the party funding a structure to disclose in writing, during negotiation, the amounts and due dates of the payments, the premium payable to the annuity issuer, and the discounted present value of payments that are not life-contingent along with the discount rate used. Florida Statutes 626.99296
The premium is what the future payments cost today. Set beside the cash offer, it shows whether the structured offer and the lump sum offer are really worth the same.
What to ask your attorney before you choose
- What does the annuity cost the defendant, and how does that compare with the cash offer?
- Which insurance company would issue the annuity, and what is my state's guaranty limit?
- Can I take part in cash and structure the rest?
- How are attorney fees and liens paid under each option?
- Do I receive public benefits that a lump sum could affect?
- If I die before the payments end, who receives them?
This page does not recommend either choice. For the basics of how structures are built, see structured settlements, explained.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. section 104, Compensation for injuries or sickness
received (whether by suit or agreement and whether as lump sums or as periodic payments) on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness
- IRS, Topic no. 403, Interest received
is taxable income in the year it becomes available to you
- 26 U.S.C. section 130, Certain personal injury liability assignments
such periodic payments cannot be accelerated, deferred, increased, or decreased by the recipient of such payments
- National Structured Settlements Trade Association, Frequently Asked Questions
The defendant then assigns this obligation to an assignment company that funds the periodic payment obligation with an annuity.
- National Structured Settlements Trade Association, What are Structured Settlements?
A structured settlement is a stream of periodic payments paid to an injured party by the defendant primarily through the purchase of an annuity
- IRS, Tax implications of settlements and judgments
the two most common exceptions are amounts paid for certain discrimination claims and amounts paid on account of physical injury
- National Structured Settlements Trade Association, Injured People
Payments can begin immediately
- 26 U.S.C. section 5891, Structured settlement factoring transactions
a tax equal to 40 percent of the factoring discount
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, CFPB Sues Access Funding (Nov. 21, 2016)
typically represented only about 30 percent of the present value
- NOLHGA, FAQs: Product coverage
up to $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits
- Florida Statutes section 626.99296, Transfers of structured settlement payment rights
The court has determined that the net amount payable to the payee is fair, just, and reasonable under the circumstances then existing.