Pain and suffering calculator

This calculator shows two estimates side by side: your medical costs times a multiplier from 1.5 to 5, and a daily dollar amount times your days of recovery. Neither method is law. Jurors in North Carolina are told there is no fixed formula for placing a value on pain and suffering, so both figures are rough starting points, according to the state's pattern jury instruction.

By , Paralegal· Checked ·5 min read ·9 sources

$
$

Two rules of thumb

$0

See which companies fund your case

Neither method is law. Jurors are told to use their judgment, and some states cap this kind of damages.

Key points

  • The multiplier method is medical costs times a number from 1.5 to 5; the per diem method is a daily amount times days of recovery.
  • New Jersey's Supreme Court barred per diem arguments in 1958; California's allowed them in 1966 and counted 21 jurisdictions that did the same.
  • We found no authoritative source for the 1.5 to 5 range or for any daily rate.
  • Maryland caps non-economic damages at a base of $500,000 that rises by $15,000 each October 1.

The two methods

The multiplier method takes your medical costs and multiplies them by a number you choose between 1.5 and 5. Nothing in the law tells you which number to pick.

The per diem method takes a daily dollar amount you choose and multiplies it by the number of days you spent recovering. A law review article describes the courtroom version, in which a small amount per unit of time is multiplied by the plaintiff's life expectancy. Northwestern University Law Review This calculator uses days of recovery instead.

The calculator shows both results next to each other and does not average them. When the two are far apart, that gap is the honest answer: these are rules of thumb, and they often disagree.

What do jury instructions say about pain and suffering?

Jury instructions on pain and suffering give jurors no formula. North Carolina's pattern instruction says there is no fixed formula for placing a value on physical pain and mental suffering, and that jurors decide fair compensation by applying logic and common sense to the evidence. North Carolina Pattern Jury Instruction 810.08

Courts have said the same for decades. New Jersey's Supreme Court wrote in 1958 that there can be no fixed basis, table, standard or mathematical rule to guide these awards. Botta v. Brunner A 2006 law review article summed up the position: jurors are given vague instructions to reasonably compensate the plaintiff. Northwestern University Law Review

Where each method comes from

The per diem method is an argument lawyers make to juries, and courts split on whether to allow it. In Botta v. Brunner, New Jersey's high court refused to let counsel suggest a price per hour or day. Botta v. Brunner Eight years later California's Supreme Court held it was error to bar the argument, and counted 21 jurisdictions that permitted it. Beagle v. Vasold A North Carolina appeals court approved a per diem argument in a 1982 car accident case. Weeks v. Holsclaw

Those rulings are old, and the rule in your state may have changed. None of them sets a daily rate. The amount you enter is your own assumption.

The multiplier comes from settlement practice. RAND researchers wrote that general damages in auto injury claims are usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses. RAND Institute for Civil Justice We found no government, bar association or peer-reviewed source that supports the 1.5 to 5 range.

State caps on non-economic damages

Some states put a ceiling on pain and suffering awards. The calculator does not apply any cap, so check whether one of these limits, or a similar law in your state, sits below your result.

StateApplies toLimit in the statute
Maryland Personal injury actions$500,000 base, plus $15,000 each October 1 since 1995
Idaho Personal injury actions, per claimant$250,000 base, adjusted each July 1 since 2004
California Medical malpractice, non-death cases$350,000 from 2023, plus $40,000 each January 1 for 10 years
Caps as written in Md. Code, Courts and Judicial Proceedings 11-108; Idaho Code 6-1603; California Civil Code 3333.2.

Sources: Maryland Code 11-108, Idaho Code 6-1603, California Civil Code 3333.2. These are examples and not a full list. Ask your attorney for the current dollar figure in your state.

What neither number can tell you

Neither method measures how an injury changed your life, how a jury would react to you, or what an insurer will pay. Both ignore your share of fault, policy limits, fees and liens. The personal injury settlement calculator adds economic losses and fault, and the guide to what a case is worth covers the public data.

Sources

  1. North Carolina Pattern Jury Instructions, Civil 810.08, Personal Injury Damages: Pain and Suffering (UNC School of Government) There is no fixed formula for placing a value on physical pain and mental suffering.
  2. Avraham, Putting a Price on Pain-and-Suffering Damages, 100 Northwestern University Law Review 87 (2006) a system of age-adjusted multipliers would be assigned to plaintiffs’ medical costs
  3. Botta v. Brunner, 26 N.J. 82 (1958), Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project There is and there can be no fixed basis, table, standard, or mathematical rule which will serve as an accurate index and guide
  4. Beagle v. Vasold, 65 Cal.2d 166 (1966), Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project Twenty-one jurisdictions which have passed on the issue permit an attorney to make the
  5. Weeks v. Holsclaw, 55 N.C. App. 335 (1982), Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project the fact that he was paid for sick leave, you are not to give the defendant the benefit of that
  6. RAND Institute for Civil Justice, How Big Is the Price Tag for Excess Auto Injury Claims? (research brief RB-9023-1) The availability of general damages and the fact that they are usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses
  7. Maryland Code, Courts and Judicial Proceedings, section 11-108 an award for noneconomic damages may not exceed $500,000
  8. Idaho Code section 6-1603, Limitation on noneconomic damages exceeding the maximum amount of two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000)
  9. California Civil Code section 3333.2 (California Legislative Information) shall not exceed three hundred fifty thousand dollars ($350,000)

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options