Key points
- Settled civil cases took a median of 267 days from filing, and a quarter took longer than 650 days.
- Only 40% of settled cases closed within 180 days of filing; 70% closed within 540 days.
- In a study of one large funder, cases took a median of 417 days from the first advance to completion.
- New York, Pennsylvania and Florida each give the paying side 20 or 21 days to send the money once a settlement is reached or a release is signed.
What court records show
The NCSC study covered civil cases closed between July 1, 2012 and June 30, 2013 in 152 courts. It identified 84,992 cases that ended in a recorded settlement and measured each from the filing date to the closing date. National Center for State Courts, 2015
- Fastest quarter
- A quarter of settled cases closed within 78 days of filing.
Settlement 84,992 478 78 267 650
iaals.du.edu - Median
- Half of settled cases closed within 267 days of filing.
Settlement 84,992 478 78 267 650
iaals.du.edu - Average
- The average settled case took 478 days.
Settlement 84,992 478 78 267 650
iaals.du.edu - Slowest quarter
- A quarter of settled cases took longer than 650 days.
Settlement 84,992 478 78 267 650
iaals.du.edu
Against the calendar, 40% of settled cases closed within 180 days, 59% within 365 days and 70% within 540 days. Settlement was one of the slower ways for a case to end. Default judgments, by comparison, closed within a year 94% of the time. National Center for State Courts, 2015
The settlement count is a floor. The report says it is likely that a substantial proportion of the cases recorded as dismissals were settlements too, because court staff may code a settled case only as a dismissal.
Injury cases specifically
The study's timing tables do not split settlements by case type. For tort cases as a group, counting every kind of ending, the median was 340 days and the average was 486 days. Car accident cases closed within a year 57% of the time. For medical malpractice cases the share was 36%. National Center for State Courts, 2015
Those are filing-to-closing times. For how the months divide up between discovery, motions and trial, see the personal injury lawsuit timeline.
How long does a settlement take if no lawsuit is filed?
No public dataset tracks how long a settlement takes when no lawsuit is filed. Court statistics start on the filing date, so a claim that settles in the insurance stage never appears in the National Center for State Courts or Bureau of Justice Statistics figures.
The nearest evidence comes from a Cornell Law Review study of one large litigation funder's files. Clients first contacted the funder a median of 308 days after the accident, and cases took a median of 417 days from the first advance to completion. Avraham and Sebok, Cornell Law Review Completion in that study means the funder was repaid, so the 417 days includes the wait for the check as well as the negotiation.
Why most cases end without a trial
Trials are rare. In the Bureau of Justice Statistics 2005 survey, about 3% of general civil cases in the courts that reported both counts were disposed through trial. Bureau of Justice Statistics, civil trials 2005 Bench and jury trials made up an estimated 4% of tort dispositions. Bureau of Justice Statistics, tort trials summary
No rule fixes the moment a case settles. In federal court, Rule 16 lists facilitating settlement among the purposes of a pretrial conference, and the judge's scheduling order limits the time to complete discovery and file motions. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16 Your attorney can tell you whether a settlement conference or mediation is on the calendar.
Settlements that need a judge's approval
Some settlements are not final when both sides sign. A court or agency has to approve them first, and that adds time.
- Class actions: in federal court a class settlement can be made only with the court's approval, after notice to the class and a hearing. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23 See how long a class action takes.
- Workers' compensation: in California, settlements must be reviewed by a workers' compensation judge. California Division of Workers' Compensation See workers' comp settlement timing.
- Other cases: New York's payment statute has a separate provision for actions that require judicial approval of a settlement. New York CPLR 5003-a Ask your attorney whether yours is one.
How long after a settlement do you get paid?
Payment after a settlement is due in 20 or 21 days under the three state rules we checked, plus the time your attorney needs to clear liens and costs. New York gives a settling defendant 21 days from the day you tender a signed release. New York CPLR 5003-a Pennsylvania and Florida set 20 days. The full breakdown is on the settlement check page.
What to ask your attorney
- Has an offer been made, and what is holding up the next one?
- Is mediation or a settlement conference scheduled?
- Will this settlement need approval from a judge or an agency?
- Once we sign, what has to be paid out of the settlement before my share?
The last question matters as much as the timing. Who gets paid first from a settlement walks through the order.
Sources
- National Center for State Courts, The Landscape of Civil Litigation in State Courts (2015)
On average, tort cases took 16 months
- Avraham and Sebok, An Empirical Investigation of Third Party Consumer Litigant Funding, 104 Cornell L. Rev. 1133 (2019)
417 days (median) for the case to be completed.
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Civil Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (NCJ 223851)
required an additional half year for a jury trial (27 months),
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005, summary page
Together, bench and jury trials accounted for an estimated 4% of all tort dispositions in 2005.
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 16
within the earlier of 90 days after any defendant has been served with the complaint or 60 days after any defendant has appeared
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 23
the court may approve it only after a hearing and only on finding that it is fair, reasonable, and adequate
- California Division of Workers' Compensation, How is my case resolved
The claims administrator agrees on an amount to resolve your claim.
- New York Civil Practice Law and Rules, section 5003-a, Prompt payment following settlement
shall pay all sums due to any settling plaintiff within twenty-one days of tender