Key points
- Consumer finance class settlements took a median of 560 days and an average of 690 days from complaint to final approval.
- Federal class settlements approved in 2006 and 2007 took a median of 1,068 days and an average of 1,196 days.
- Only about 15% of the consumer finance class cases the CFPB tracked ended in an approved class settlement.
- In settlements that required a claim form, the median claims rate was 8%.
What the two studies found
- CFPB, 419 settlements
- Consumer finance class settlements approved from 2008 to 2012 took a median of 560 days and an average of 690 days from the initial complaint to the final approval order.
The median time to approval of the final settlement was 560 days and the average time
files.consumerfinance.gov - Fitzpatrick, federal courts
- Federal class settlements from 2006 and 2007 had an average case duration of 1,196 days and a median of 1,068 days, as reported in the CFPB study.
the average case duration was 1,196 days, and the median case duration was 1,068 days
files.consumerfinance.gov
The second study, by Professor Brian Fitzpatrick, covers the entire body of federal class action settlements from those two years, not only consumer finance. The figures here are taken from the CFPB report, which cites it. The CFPB noted that its own consumer finance cases settled somewhat more quickly than the broader federal set. CFPB Arbitration Study, 2015
Both studies stop the clock at final approval. Neither measures when class members were paid.
Most class cases never reach a class settlement
The CFPB also followed 562 consumer finance class actions filed in federal and selected state courts from 2010 to 2012. About 12% had reached final approval of a class settlement by February 2014, and the share rose to 15% after six more months of docket review. About 25% were resolved through individual settlements. CFPB Arbitration Study, 2015
Counting every kind of ending, class cases closed sooner. For cases filed in 2010, the median time to closure was 218 days in federal court outside multidistrict litigation, 407 days in state court and 758 days inside multidistrict litigation. The CFPB cautioned that these figures were incomplete because some cases were still open.
Why court approval takes months
A class settlement binds people who never hired the lawyers, so federal rules put a judge between the deal and the money. A certified class's claims may be settled only with the court's approval. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23
- The parties first give the court enough information to decide whether to notify the class.
- The court directs notice to all class members who would be bound.
- Any class member may object to the proposal.
- The court may approve the settlement only after a hearing and only on finding that it is fair, reasonable, and adequate.
The judge in the case sets the dates for each step.
Bigger settlements take longer
In the CFPB data, settlements with smaller recoveries tended to settle faster than those with larger ones, and the relationship between settlement size and days to settlement was roughly linear. CFPB Arbitration Study, 2015
How long after final approval do class members get paid?
No public dataset tracks how long class members wait for payment after final approval of a class action settlement. Both the CFPB study and the Fitzpatrick study end at the approval order. The schedule depends on the settlement's own terms, on whether anyone appeals the approval, and on how long the claims process runs.
The settlement notice or the settlement website is the place to look for a payment schedule. Questions go to the settlement administrator or class counsel named in the notice.
Many class members never file a claim
Being in the class does not always mean being paid. In 105 settlements that required a claim and reported the numbers, the CFPB found an average claims rate of 21% and a median of 8%. Weighted by class size, the rate was 4% including one settlement with 190 million class members, and 11% without it. CFPB Arbitration Study, 2015
About 130 of the settlements the CFPB reviewed paid at least some class members automatically, with no claim form. If you receive a class notice, check which kind yours is and note the claim deadline.
Class action or individual lawsuit?
A class action is different from an individual injury lawsuit, where you hire your own attorney and control your own settlement. Individual tort cases move faster: half closed within 340 days of filing in a National Center for State Courts study. See how long a lawsuit takes and how long a settlement takes.
If you are not sure which kind of case you have, ask the attorney who represents you whether you signed an individual fee agreement or are only a member of a class.
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Arbitration Study: Report to Congress (March 2015)
The median time to approval of the final settlement was 560 days and the average time
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 23
the court may approve it only after a hearing and only on finding that it is fair, reasonable, and adequate