Contingency fees, explained

A contingency fee is a lawyer's fee paid as a percentage of what you recover, and owed only if you recover something. One-third is the figure with the best data behind it: a study of New York City closing statements found fees were almost always one-third of the net recovery, the maximum allowed there. Helland et al., Vanderbilt Law Review ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) requires the agreement to be in writing and signed by you. ABA Model Rule 1.5

By , Paralegal· Checked ·6 min read ·7 sources

Key points

  • ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) requires a contingency fee agreement to be in writing, signed by the client, and to state the percentage and the expenses.
  • In New York City closing statements from 2004 to 2013, attorney's fees were almost always one-third of net recovery.
  • Florida's bar rules presume a fee is excessive above 33 1/3% before an answer is filed or 40% after, on the first $1 million.
  • Federal law caps fees at 25% of a judgment or settlement in a suit under the Federal Tort Claims Act.

What the fee agreement must say

Under the ABA model rule, a contingent fee agreement must be in a writing signed by the client and must state:

  • the method for determining the fee, including the percentage that goes to the lawyer if the case ends in settlement, trial or appeal;
  • the litigation and other expenses to be deducted from the recovery;
  • whether those expenses are deducted before or after the fee is calculated;
  • any expenses you will owe whether or not you win.

At the end of the case the lawyer must give you a written statement of the outcome and how your share was calculated. ABA Model Rule 1.5 That document is covered in how to read a settlement statement.

How much lawyers charge

No national dataset records the percentage in every contingency fee agreement. The best public evidence comes from New York, where lawyers must file closing statements with the courts. In a study of those filings for 2004 to 2013, attorney's fees were almost always one-third of net recovery. Helland et al., Vanderbilt Law Review In a hand-coded sample from the same study, only three cases had fees below 30% and only two had fees above 40%. Helland et al., full text

An agreement can set a higher percentage if the case goes further. The model rule allows for this, since it requires the agreement to state the percentages for settlement, trial and appeal separately. Florida's limits, for example, step up from 33 1/3% to 40% once the defendant files an answer.

Caps set by statute or court rule

JurisdictionApplies toCap
Florida Personal injury and property damage33 1/3% before an answer, 40% after, on the first $1 million; 30% on the next $1 million; 20% above $2 million
California Medical malpractice25% if settled before filing; 33% after filing
New York Medical malpractice30% of the first $250,000, sliding down to 10% above $1.25 million
Federal Federal Tort Claims Act25% of a judgment or settlement in suit; 20% of an agency settlement
Examples of contingency fee limits. Sources: The Florida Bar; California Business and Professions Code 6146; New York Judiciary Law 474-a; 28 U.S.C. 2678.

Florida's figures are presumptions. The Florida Bar says a lawyer who charges more is presumed to be charging an excessive fee unless a court approved it in advance, and that you and your attorney may agree to a lower percentage. The Florida Bar, Attorneys' Fees

California's limits apply to claims against health care providers for professional negligence, and a court can approve a higher fee for good cause when a case is tried or arbitrated. California Business and Professions Code 6146 New York's schedule is computed on the net sum after certain expenses. New York Judiciary Law 474-a The federal cap covers claims against the United States. 28 U.S.C. 2678

These are examples. Ask your attorney whether your state or your type of case has a cap.

Costs are separate from the fee

The percentage pays for the lawyer's work. Case expenses, such as filing fees, records and expert witnesses, are counted separately. The Florida Bar warns that if your agreement makes you responsible for costs, they will have to be paid even if you lose and the lawyer collects no fee. The Florida Bar, Attorneys' Fees

In the New York City study, median litigation expenses were 3% of the gross recovery. Helland et al., Vanderbilt Law Review That is a median from one city, and cases with experts or a trial cost more.

Is a contingency fee calculated before or after expenses?

A contingency fee can be calculated before or after expenses, and ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) requires the fee agreement to say which. ABA Model Rule 1.5 The difference is real money. On a $60,000 settlement with $3,000 in costs and a one-third fee, taking the fee after costs leaves you $1,000 more than taking it on the gross.

New York's general practice is to compute the fee on the net: the study of its closing statements describes fees as one-third of net recovery, meaning total recovery minus expenses. Helland et al., full text

What makes a fee reasonable

Every fee, contingent or not, has to be reasonable under Model Rule 1.5(a). The rule lists eight factors, including the time and labor required, the fee customarily charged in the locality, the amount involved and the results obtained, and whether the fee is fixed or contingent. ABA Model Rule 1.5

Two kinds of case cannot be taken on contingency at all under the model rule: a divorce where the fee depends on securing the divorce or on the amount of support or property, and the defense of a criminal case.

Can you negotiate a contingency fee?

A contingency fee can be negotiated before you sign. The caps described above are ceilings, and the Florida Bar tells consumers directly that a client and attorney may agree to a lesser percentage than the limits. The Florida Bar, Attorneys' Fees Ask what percentage applies at each stage, who pays costs if the case is lost, and whether the fee is taken before or after costs.

How the fee fits with everything else

The fee is the first deduction from a settlement, followed by costs, medical liens and any lawsuit loan, also called pre-settlement funding. Who gets paid first from a settlement sets out the order. If part of your settlement is taxable, the fee can affect the tax as well. See are settlements taxable.

Sources

  1. Helland, Klerman, Dowling and Kappner, Contingent Fee Litigation in New York City, 70 Vand. L. Rev. 1971 (2017), abstract are almost always one-third of net recovery, which is the maximum allowed by law
  2. American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5: Fees Upon conclusion of a contingent fee matter, the lawyer shall provide the client with a written statement
  3. Helland, Klerman, Dowling and Kappner, Contingent Fee Litigation in New York City, 70 Vand. L. Rev. 1971 (2017), full text Median expenses were 3% of recoveries.
  4. The Florida Bar, consumer pamphlet: Attorneys' Fees 33 1/3 percent of any recovery up to $1 million
  5. California Business and Professions Code, section 6146 Twenty-five percent of the dollar amount recovered if the recovery is pursuant to settlement agreement and release of all claims
  6. New York Judiciary Law, section 474-a 30 percent of the first $250,000 of the sum recovered
  7. Federal Tort Claims Act, 28 U.S.C. section 2678, Attorney fees; penalty fees in excess of 25 per centum of any judgment rendered

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options