How to read a settlement statement, line by line

A settlement statement, also called a closing statement, shows the gross settlement, the attorney's fee, case costs, liens and other repayments, and the net amount paid to you. In a contingency fee case, ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) requires the lawyer to give you a written statement showing the outcome, the remittance to you and the method of its determination. ABA Model Rule 1.5

By , Paralegal· Checked ·5 min read ·7 sources

Key points

  • ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) requires a written statement at the end of every contingency fee matter.
  • Florida requires the statement to itemize all costs and expenses and to be signed by both you and your lawyer.
  • In a study of New York City closing statements, median litigation expenses were 3% of the recovery.
  • Whether the fee is taken before or after expenses must be stated in the fee agreement, and it changes your net.

What the rule requires

The ABA rule has two parts. At the start, the fee agreement must be in writing, signed by you, and must state the lawyer's percentage, the expenses to be deducted, and whether expenses come out before or after the fee is calculated. At the end, the lawyer must provide a written statement of the outcome and, if there is a recovery, the remittance to the client and how it was determined. ABA Model Rule 1.5

States build on that model. The Florida Bar tells consumers that the lawyer must give a written statement of the amount recovered and how it is calculated, plus an itemized bill showing all of the costs and expenses, and that the statement must be signed by the client and the lawyers. The Florida Bar, Attorneys' Fees New York courts have required contingent fee lawyers to file closing statements since 1957. Helland et al., Vanderbilt Law Review

The lines, in order

  • Gross settlement. The full amount the defendant or insurer agreed to pay. Check it against the settlement agreement or release you signed.
  • Attorney's fee. The percentage in your fee agreement, applied to the gross amount or to the amount left after expenses, whichever the agreement says.
  • Costs and expenses. Money the firm spent on the case, such as court filing fees, records, deposition transcripts and expert witnesses.
  • Medical liens and reimbursements. Amounts owed to Medicare, Medicaid, a health plan or a provider that paid for or supplied your treatment.
  • Lawsuit loan payoff. If you took a lawsuit loan, also called pre-settlement funding, the amount owed to the funder on the payoff date.
  • Net to client. What is left. This is the check you receive.

Some statements also show money already advanced to you, or a holdback kept in trust until a lien is settled. Ask what each one is for and when any holdback will be released.

Fee before or after costs: the difference in dollars

The order of two lines changes your net. Take a $60,000 settlement, $3,000 in case costs and a one-third fee.

MethodAttorney's feeCostsLeft before liens
Fee on the gross $20,000$3,000$37,000
Fee after costs $19,000$3,000$38,000
Difference $1,000None$1,000
Arithmetic example with assumed figures. It is not drawn from a real case.

Neither method is improper. The ABA rule requires the agreement to say which one applies, so compare the statement to the agreement you signed. ABA Model Rule 1.5

What costs look like in real cases

A study of closing statements filed in New York City from 2004 to 2013 gives a benchmark. Median litigation expenses, other than attorney's fees, were 3% of the gross recovery. Helland et al., Vanderbilt Law Review In a hand-coded sample from the same study, experts were hired in 21% of cases at an average of $3,654 per case, and court fees averaged $321 in cases where suit was filed. Helland et al., full text

Those are figures from one city, and the study found that the expense share rose as a case went through more procedural stages. A case with several experts or a trial can cost much more. The useful check is whether each cost on your statement is itemized and matches a real expense.

Liens and loan payoffs

Lien lines can be large, and some can be reduced. Medicare's regulation sets out a formula that lowers its recovery by its share of your attorney's fees and costs. 42 CFR 411.37 Other payers follow different rules. See medical liens on a settlement.

A funding payoff grows with time. In a Cornell Law Review study of one large funder, the median amount advanced on completed cases was $2,250 and the median amount due at the end was $4,849. Avraham and Sebok, Cornell Law Review Ask for the funder's written payoff letter and check that its date matches the statement. The order in which all of these are paid is covered in who gets paid first.

Do you have to sign the settlement statement?

Whether you have to sign the settlement statement depends on your state. Florida requires the statement to be signed by the client and the lawyers who represented the client. The Florida Bar, Attorneys' Fees The ABA model rule requires the lawyer to provide the statement but does not mention a client signature. Ask your attorney what your state requires, and do not sign until every line has been explained.

If a number looks wrong

Start by asking for the documents behind the line: the fee agreement, receipts for costs, the lien holder's final letter, the funder's payoff letter. A lawyer must, on request, promptly give a full accounting of client funds. ABA Model Rule 1.15

If you still disagree, the same rule protects the rest of your money. The lawyer must keep the disputed portion separate until the dispute is resolved and must promptly distribute the portions that are not in dispute. Your state bar can explain its fee dispute process.

Sources

  1. American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5: Fees Upon conclusion of a contingent fee matter, the lawyer shall provide the client with a written statement
  2. The Florida Bar, consumer pamphlet: Attorneys' Fees 33 1/3 percent of any recovery up to $1 million
  3. Helland, Klerman, Dowling and Kappner, Contingent Fee Litigation in New York City, 70 Vand. L. Rev. 1971 (2017), abstract are almost always one-third of net recovery, which is the maximum allowed by law
  4. Helland, Klerman, Dowling and Kappner, Contingent Fee Litigation in New York City, 70 Vand. L. Rev. 1971 (2017), full text Median expenses were 3% of recoveries.
  5. Code of Federal Regulations, 42 CFR 411.37, Amount of Medicare recovery when a primary payment is made as a result of a judgment or settlement Subtract the Medicare share of procurement costs from the Medicare payments.
  6. Avraham and Sebok, An Empirical Investigation of Third Party Consumer Litigant Funding, 104 Cornell L. Rev. 1133 (2019) 417 days (median) for the case to be completed.
  7. American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.15: Safekeeping Property a lawyer shall promptly deliver to the client or third person any funds or other property

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options