Medical liens on a settlement

Anyone who paid for your accident-related care may have a legal right to be repaid from your settlement. Medicare's right is the strictest: federal regulations require reimbursement within 60 days after you or another party receives the settlement payment. 42 CFR 411.24 Medicaid, employer health plans and hospitals each follow different rules, and some of those rules cap what can be taken.

By , Paralegal· Checked ·6 min read ·10 sources

Key points

  • Medicare must be reimbursed within 60 days after a settlement payment is received, and it can recover from an attorney or insurer as well as from you.
  • Medicare reduces its claim by its share of your attorney's fees and costs under 42 CFR 411.37.
  • A state Medicaid program can reach only the part of a settlement that represents medical care, past or future.
  • Illinois caps all health care provider liens at 40% of a settlement.

The four kinds of claims

Who paidWhere the right comes fromMain limit
Medicare Federal Medicare Secondary Payer lawReduced by its share of fees and costs
Medicaid Federal Medicaid Act and state lawOnly the medical-care part of the settlement
Employer health plan The plan's own terms, enforced under ERISAWhatever the plan document says
Hospital or doctor State lien statuteState cap, where one exists
Common medical claims against an injury settlement. Sources: 42 CFR 411.24 and 411.37; Arkansas DHHS v. Ahlborn; Gallardo v. Marstiller; US Airways v. McCutchen; 770 ILCS 23/10.

The word lien is used loosely for all four. Strictly, some are liens and some are rights of reimbursement. What matters to you is the same: the money comes out of the settlement before your share.

Medicare

When a liability insurer is expected to pay for an injury, Medicare can still pay your bills in the meantime. CMS calls this a conditional payment, because it must be repaid when a settlement, judgment or award is made. CMS, Medicare Secondary Payer

The process has fixed steps. The case is reported to Medicare's Benefits Coordination and Recovery Center, which sends a Rights and Responsibilities letter. Within 65 days of that letter it sends a conditional payment letter listing what Medicare has paid so far. CMS, Medicare's Recovery Process After the settlement is reported, a demand letter states the final amount. CMS, Reimbursing Medicare

Two rules explain why attorneys treat this claim with care. Medicare has a right of action against any entity that received the payment, including a beneficiary, an attorney or a private insurer. 42 CFR 411.24 Interest accrues from the date of the demand letter and is assessed if the debt is not resolved in the time the letter gives, even while an appeal or waiver request is pending.

Medicaid

Medicaid is run by the states under federal law. As a condition of coverage you assign the state your right to payment for medical care from a third party. The Supreme Court held in Arkansas DHHS v. Ahlborn that the state cannot take more than the part of a settlement that represents medical expenses. Federal law bars a lien on the remainder. Arkansas DHHS v. Ahlborn

In 2022 the Court clarified how far the medical part reaches. Gallardo v. Marstiller held that the Medicaid Act permits a state to seek reimbursement from settlement payments allocated for future medical care, not only past care. Gallardo v. Marstiller How a settlement is divided between medical and other damages can therefore change what the state may claim.

Employer health plans

Many employer health plans are governed by a federal law called ERISA, and their repayment rights come from the plan document. In US Airways v. McCutchen the Supreme Court held that the plan's terms govern, and that general fairness doctrines cannot override a clear reimbursement clause.

The same case helps plan members on one point. When the plan is silent on attorney's fees, the common-fund doctrine is the default rule, which means the plan shares in the cost of obtaining the recovery. US Airways v. McCutchen Ask your attorney to get the plan document itself, not just a letter from a collection vendor.

Hospital and provider lien statutes

State statutes let hospitals and other providers claim unpaid bills directly from an injury recovery. The terms vary widely, and two examples show the range.

  • Illinois gives every health care professional and provider a lien on the injured person's claim, but the total of all such liens may not exceed 40% of the verdict, judgment, award or settlement. 770 ILCS 23/10
  • Virginia limits the lien to $2,500 for a hospital or nursing home, $750 for each physician, nurse, physical therapist or pharmacy, and $200 for each emergency medical services provider. Code of Virginia 8.01-66.2

These are examples, not a 50-state survey. Your attorney will know your state's statute and whether a provider followed its notice requirements.

Can a medical lien be reduced?

A medical lien can be reduced in several ways, and the method depends on who holds it. Medicare applies a formula in 42 CFR 411.37: it works out the ratio of your attorney's fees and costs to the settlement, applies that ratio to its payments, and subtracts the result from its claim. 42 CFR 411.37 CMS also lets you dispute charges on the conditional payment letter that are unrelated to the injury, and request a waiver of recovery.

For other payers the tools are the limits already described: the medical-expense limit for Medicaid, the plan's own wording for employer plans, and statutory caps for providers. Reductions are negotiated by your attorney and should appear on your settlement statement.

What to ask your attorney

  • Which payers have given notice of a claim, and for how much?
  • Has Medicare or Medicaid issued a final demand, or only an interim figure?
  • Are any charges on the lien unrelated to this injury?
  • What reduction has been requested from each lien holder?
  • Will any money be held back in trust while a lien is disputed?

Liens are one reason a check takes time after a settlement. See how long it takes to get a settlement check and who gets paid first.

Sources

  1. Code of Federal Regulations, 42 CFR 411.24, Recovery of conditional payments the beneficiary or other party must reimburse Medicare within 60 days
  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Medicare Secondary Payer A conditional payment is a payment Medicare makes for services another payer may be responsible for.
  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Medicare's Recovery Process Within 65 days of the issuance of the RAR Letter, the BCRC will send the CPL and Payment Summary Form (PSF).
  4. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Reimbursing Medicare Interest accrues from the date of the demand letter, but is only assessed if the debt is not repaid or otherwise resolved
  5. Arkansas Department of Health and Human Services v. Ahlborn, 547 U.S. 268 (2006), syllabus the anti-lien provision precludes attachment or encumbrance of the remainder of the settlement
  6. Gallardo v. Marstiller, 596 U.S. 420 (2022) The Medicaid Act permits a State to seek reimbursement from settlement payments allocated for future medical care.
  7. US Airways, Inc. v. McCutchen, 569 U.S. 88 (2013) the common-fund doctrine provides the appropriate default rule to fill that gap
  8. Illinois Health Care Services Lien Act, 770 ILCS 23/10 not exceed 40% of the verdict, judgment, award, settlement, or
  9. Code of Virginia, section 8.01-66.2, Lien against person whose negligence causes injury but not exceeding $2,500 in the case of a hospital or nursing home
  10. Code of Federal Regulations, 42 CFR 411.37, Amount of Medicare recovery when a primary payment is made as a result of a judgment or settlement Subtract the Medicare share of procurement costs from the Medicare payments.

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options