Key points
- The average auto liability claim was $28,278 for bodily injury and $6,770 for property damage in 2024, according to ISO data published by the Insurance Information Institute.
- No statute or jury instruction sets a pain and suffering multiplier, and we found no authoritative source for the 1.5 to 5 range.
- RAND researchers describe general damages in auto claims as usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses.
- Florida bars any recovery for a person more than 50 percent at fault, while Washington only reduces the award in proportion to fault.
What the calculator adds up
Economic damages are the losses that come with paperwork. The calculator adds four of them: medical bills to date, expected future medical costs, lost wages and property damage.
Non-economic damages stand in for pain and suffering. The calculator takes your medical costs, past and future, and multiplies them by the number you pick between 1.5 and 5. Lost wages and property damage are not multiplied.
It then adds the two figures and multiplies the sum by one minus your fault share. If you enter 20 percent fault, the total falls by 20 percent.
Where the multiplier comes from
No statute sets a multiplier, and jurors are never told to use one. North Carolina's pattern instruction, for example, tells jurors there is no fixed formula for placing a value on physical pain and mental suffering, and that they should apply logic and common sense to the evidence. North Carolina Pattern Jury Instruction 810.08
The multiplier comes from settlement practice. RAND researchers who studied auto injury claims wrote that general damages "are usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses." RAND Institute for Civil Justice That sentence describes how negotiators work. It does not say which multiple applies to any injury.
We looked for a government, bar association or peer-reviewed source that supports the 1.5 to 5 range and found none. We also looked for verifiable research on the claim software insurers use and found none we could rely on. Treat the multiplier as a way to see how far the answer moves, not as a finding about your case.
How does your share of fault change a car accident settlement?
Your share of fault reduces a car accident settlement in most states, and in some states it can erase the claim. Washington reduces the award in proportion to the claimant's fault and does not bar recovery, under RCW 4.22.005. Florida bars any recovery for a party found more than 50 percent at fault, under Florida Statutes 768.81.
Minnesota allows recovery only if your fault was not greater than the fault of the person you are claiming against. Minnesota Statutes 604.01 A few states are stricter still. Maryland's highest court wrote in 1983 that a plaintiff who fails to use ordinary care for his own safety is barred from all recovery. Harrison v. Montgomery County Board of Education
The calculator uses the simplest version. It reduces the total by your percentage and never bars the claim, so it overstates the result in states with a cutoff once your share passes that line. The glossary entry on comparative negligence explains the versions.
What the estimate cannot tell you
The result is a gross figure before anyone else is paid. Attorney fees, case costs and medical liens come out of a settlement first, and the what you keep calculator covers that step.
- It does not know the other driver's policy limit, which can sit below the number shown.
- It treats fault as a number you already know. In a real claim, fault is argued over.
- It assumes every medical bill is accepted as reasonable and related to the crash.
- A high multiplier on large bills produces totals far above the $28,278 average bodily injury claim.
The pages on average car accident settlements and what a case is worth set out what public data exists.
Questions to ask your attorney
- Which fault rule does my state use, and what share is the insurer likely to assign to me?
- What are the policy limits on every policy that could pay?
- Which of my medical bills is the insurer disputing?
- What have similar injuries settled for in this county?
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute, Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (ISO data)
the average auto liability claim for bodily injury was $28,278
- RAND Institute for Civil Justice, How Big Is the Price Tag for Excess Auto Injury Claims? (research brief RB-9023-1)
The availability of general damages and the fact that they are usually calculated as some multiple of economic losses
- North Carolina Pattern Jury Instructions, Civil 810.08, Personal Injury Damages: Pain and Suffering (UNC School of Government)
There is no fixed formula for placing a value on physical pain and mental suffering.
- Revised Code of Washington 4.22.005, Effect of contributory fault
any contributory fault chargeable to the claimant diminishes proportionately the amount awarded as compensatory damages
- Florida Statutes section 768.81, Comparative fault
any party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages
- Minnesota Statutes section 604.01, Comparative fault; effect
if the contributory fault was not greater than the fault of the person against whom recovery is sought
- Harrison v. Montgomery County Board of Education, 295 Md. 442 (1983), Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project
is contributorily negligent and is barred from all recovery