Comparative negligence: how your share of fault changes a claim

Comparative negligence is the rule that reduces your compensation by your own share of fault for an accident instead of throwing the claim out. Forty-six states follow some form of it. Maryland, Virginia, Alabama, North Carolina and the District of Columbia keep the older rule, contributory negligence, under which your own fault, however slight, bars recovery. Maryland Department of Legislative Services

By , Paralegal· Checked ·7 min read ·25 sources

Key points

  • Forty-six states use comparative negligence, according to Maryland's Department of Legislative Services.
  • Under a 51 percent bar, as in Texas and Florida, you recover nothing if you are more than 50 percent at fault.
  • Under a 50 percent bar, as in Idaho and Kansas, you recover nothing if your fault equals or exceeds the other side's.
  • Louisiana's 51 percent bar took effect on January 1, 2026.

The four rules

States use four main rules when the injured person shares the blame. Take a claim worth $100,000 in damages.

  • Pure comparative negligence. Your damages fall by your percentage of fault and are never barred. At 30 percent fault you receive $70,000; at 80 percent, $20,000.
  • Modified, 51 percent bar. Your damages fall by your percentage of fault, and you recover nothing once your fault is greater than 50 percent. At exactly 50 percent you receive $50,000.
  • Modified, 50 percent bar. The same reduction applies, and you recover nothing once your fault is equal to or greater than the other side's. At exactly 50 percent you receive nothing.
  • Contributory negligence. Any fault on your part can bar the claim entirely.

The dollar figures are arithmetic on the rules in the statutes cited below, not predictions.

Which rule does my state use?

Comparative negligence rules are set state by state. The table lists the rule in 27 jurisdictions, each with a link to the statute or official source we read. It is a partial list: if your state is missing, ask your attorney which rule applies.

StateRuleSource
Arizona Pure comparativeA.R.S. 12-2505
Rhode Island Pure comparativeR.I. Gen. Laws 9-20-4
Washington Pure comparativeRCW 4.22.005
Delaware Modified, 51 percent bar10 Del. C. 8132
Florida Modified, 51 percent bar (medical negligence claims excepted)Fla. Stat. 768.81
Iowa Modified, 51 percent barIowa Code 668.3
Louisiana Modified, 51 percent barLa. Civ. Code art. 2323
Massachusetts Modified, 51 percent barMass. G.L. c. 231, s. 85
Michigan Modified, 51 percent bar for non-economic damages onlyMCL 600.2959
Minnesota Modified, 51 percent barMinn. Stat. 604.01
Montana Modified, 51 percent barMont. Code 27-1-702
New Hampshire Modified, 51 percent barN.H. RSA 507:7-d
Oregon Modified, 51 percent barORS 31.600
Pennsylvania Modified, 51 percent bar42 Pa.C.S. 7102
Texas Modified, 51 percent barTex. CPRC 33.001
Vermont Modified, 51 percent bar12 V.S.A. 1036
West Virginia Modified, 51 percent barW. Va. Code 55-7-13c
Wisconsin Modified, 51 percent barWis. Stat. 895.045
Idaho Modified, 50 percent barIdaho Code 6-801
Kansas Modified, 50 percent barK.S.A. 60-258a
Maine Modified, 50 percent bar14 M.R.S. 156
Nebraska Modified, 50 percent barNeb. Rev. Stat. 25-21,185.09
Maryland Contributory negligenceMd. legislative analysis, 2026
Alabama, North Carolina, Virginia Contributory negligenceMd. legislative analysis, 2018
District of Columbia Contributory negligence, with an exception for pedestrians and other vulnerable road usersD.C. Code 50-2204.52
Fault rules in 27 jurisdictions, from the statutes and legislative analyses linked in each row. Partial list, checked November 2026.

Where contributory negligence still applies

Maryland's legislative analysts describe contributory negligence this way: an injured plaintiff's fault, however slight, is a defense to the negligence claim and bars all recovery. Their 2026 analysis says Maryland, three other states and the District of Columbia retain the doctrine. Maryland Department of Legislative Services, Fiscal and Policy Note, HB 466 (2026) The 2018 analysis names the three states as Virginia, Alabama and North Carolina. Maryland Department of Legislative Services, Fiscal and Policy Note, SB 465 (2018)

The District of Columbia has carved out an exception. A pedestrian or other vulnerable user of a public highway or sidewalk hit by a motor vehicle is not barred from recovery unless that person's negligence is greater than the combined negligence of all the defendants. D.C. Code 50-2204.52

Details that change the result

The label does not tell you everything. Florida's bar does not apply to personal injury or wrongful death claims arising out of medical negligence. Fla. Stat. 768.81 In Michigan, a person who is more than 50 percent at fault still recovers reduced economic damages but is awarded no non-economic damages. MCL 600.2959

States also differ on whose fault yours is compared with. Oregon and Montana compare it with the combined fault of the others. ORS 31.600 Mont. Code 27-1-702 Wisconsin measures the plaintiff's negligence separately against each negligent person. Wis. Stat. 895.045 With several defendants, that difference can decide the outcome.

Rules change, too. Louisiana's current article, which bars recovery at 51 percent fault, took effect on January 1, 2026. La. Civ. Code art. 2323

What comparative negligence means for your claim

Your share of fault matters in a settlement negotiation, because each percentage point comes off your compensatory damages. Our guide to how much a case is worth shows where the reduction fits.

  • Ask your attorney which rule your state uses and whether any exception fits your case.
  • Ask what percentage of fault the insurer is assigning to you, and on what evidence.
  • Ask how the result changes if a jury puts your fault at or just above 50 percent.

Sources

  1. Maryland Department of Legislative Services, Fiscal and Policy Note, SB 465 (2018) Maryland is one of five jurisdictions, along with Virginia, Alabama, North Carolina, and the District of Columbia, that retains the doctrine of contributory negligence.
  2. Maryland Department of Legislative Services, Fiscal and Policy Note, HB 466 (2026) Maryland (along with three states and the District of Columbia) retains the doctrine of contributory negligence.
  3. D.C. Code 50-2204.52 the negligence of the following shall not bar the plaintiff's recovery
  4. A.R.S. 12-2505 the claimant's action is not barred, but the full damages shall be reduced in proportion to the relative degree of the claimant's fault
  5. R.I. Gen. Laws 9-20-4 shall not bar a recovery, but damages shall be diminished by the finder of fact in proportion to the amount of negligence
  6. RCW 4.22.005 diminishes proportionately the amount awarded as compensatory damages
  7. 10 Del. C. 8132 where such negligence was not greater than the negligence of the defendant or the combined negligence of all defendants against whom recovery is sought
  8. Fla. Stat. 768.81 any party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages
  9. Iowa Code 668.3 unless the claimant bears a greater percentage of fault than the combined percentage of fault attributed to the defendants
  10. La. Civ. Code art. 2323 equal to or greater than fifty-one percent, then the person suffering injury, death, or loss shall not be entitled to recover damages
  11. Mass. G.L. c. 231, s. 85 if such negligence was not greater than the total amount of negligence attributable to the person or persons against whom recovery is sought
  12. MCL 600.2959 If that person's percentage of fault is greater than the aggregate fault of the other person or persons
  13. Minn. Stat. 604.01 if the contributory fault was not greater than the fault of the person against whom recovery is sought
  14. Mont. Code 27-1-702 if the contributory negligence was not greater than the negligence of the person or the combined negligence of all persons against whom recovery is sought
  15. N.H. RSA 507:7-d if such fault was not greater than the fault of the defendant
  16. ORS 31.600 if the fault attributable to the claimant was not greater than the combined fault of all persons
  17. 42 Pa.C.S. 7102 where such negligence was not greater than the causal negligence of the defendant or defendants against whom recovery is sought
  18. Tex. CPRC 33.001 a claimant may not recover damages if his percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent
  19. 12 V.S.A. 1036 if the negligence was not greater than the causal total negligence of the defendant or defendants
  20. W. Va. Code 55-7-13c fault is greater than the combined fault of all other persons responsible for the total amount of damages
  21. Wis. Stat. 895.045 if that negligence was not greater than the negligence of the person against whom recovery is sought
  22. Idaho Code 6-801 was not as great as the negligence, gross negligence or comparative responsibility of the person against whom recovery is sought
  23. K.S.A. 60-258a if that party's negligence was less than the causal negligence of the party or parties against whom a claim is made
  24. 14 M.R.S. 156 If such claimant is found by the jury to be equally at fault, the claimant may not recover.
  25. Neb. Rev. Stat. 25-21,185.09 equal to or greater than the total negligence of all persons against whom recovery is sought, the claimant shall be totally barred from recovery

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options