Key points
- PACCAR was decided by a majority of the Supreme Court on July 26, 2023, with Lord Sales giving the leading judgment and Lady Rose dissenting.
- The Court of Appeal held on July 4, 2025, that agreements paying the funder a multiple of its outlay are not damages-based agreements.
- The Civil Justice Council's final report of June 2, 2025, made 58 recommendations, including a statutory reversal of PACCAR and light-touch regulation of funders.
- A 2024 bill to reverse PACCAR fell at the July 2024 general election, and ministers said in November 2026 that the new fix will apply with prospective effect.
What the Supreme Court decided in PACCAR
The case, R (PACCAR Inc) v Competition Appeal Tribunal [2023] UKSC 28, arose from collective proceedings over a truck cartel. Two would-be class representatives relied on funding agreements that paid the funder a percentage of any damages. The truck makers argued that those agreements were damages-based agreements, or DBAs, under section 58AA of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 UK Supreme Court.
The question turned on whether a funder provides "claims management services", a statutory phrase that includes "the provision of financial services or assistance". The Supreme Court allowed the appeal by a majority and held that it does. A DBA is unenforceable unless it meets statutory conditions, and it was accepted that the agreements before the court did not meet them Supreme Court press summary.
Why one definition unsettled a market
Both the Competition Appeal Tribunal and the Divisional Court had held in this case that the funding agreements were not DBAs. The Supreme Court's reversal reached any agreement that pays the funder a share of the damages. The Ministry of Justice summarized the effect this way: funding agreements "are only valid if they meet strict rules and are banned in certain group claims" Ministry of Justice. The ministry also said the ruling "has resulted in a drop in collective action lawsuits".
Funders responded by rewriting agreements so that the fee is a multiple of the money laid out. Defendants challenged the rewritten agreements, and on July 4, 2025, the Court of Appeal dismissed those appeals, leaving in place the tribunal's finding that the revised agreements were not DBAs and were enforceable Sony v Neill, EWCA Civ 841.
The 2024 bill that fell
The previous government introduced the Litigation Funding Agreements (Enforceability) Bill in March 2024. The bill covered England and Wales only and was written to address the judgment Ministry of Justice. Parliament's record shows it started in the House of Lords and never became an Act UK Parliament bill record.
The Civil Justice Council's account is short: "With the general election in July 2024, the Bill fell" Civil Justice Council. The incoming government said it would decide on legislation once the council had reported.
What the Civil Justice Council recommended
The Civil Justice Council published its final report on June 2, 2025 Judiciary of England and Wales. The report runs to 58 recommendations. Its first is that PACCAR be reversed by legislation that is "both retrospective and prospective in effect" Civil Justice Council.
- Regulator
- Funding should be regulated by statutory regulations made by the Lord Chancellor, with the question of moving to the Financial Conduct Authority revisited after five years.
Regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is not recommended at this stage
judiciary.uk - Commercial parties
- The report separates commercial deals from consumer and group claims and says commercial parties need little protection.
Regulation where commercial parties are concerned need be minimal.
judiciary.uk - Baseline rules
- All funders would face case-specific capital adequacy rules, a ban on controlling the litigation, conflict rules and early disclosure of the funder's name and the source of its money.
codification of the requirement that litigation funders should not control funded litigation
judiciary.uk - Caps on returns
- The working party declined to cap what funders can earn. In collective proceedings it proposed court approval of whether the return is fair, just and reasonable.
The Working Party rejects the introduction of caps on litigation funder’s returns.
judiciary.uk - Portfolio funding
- Funding of a law firm's book of cases would be treated as lending and supervised by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Portfolio funding should be regulated as a form of loan.
judiciary.uk
Has the UK reversed PACCAR?
The UK has not reversed PACCAR as of November 18, 2026. The Ministry of Justice announced on December 17, 2025, that it would legislate to make clear that litigation funding agreements are not damages-based agreements, and added that the bill would come "when parliamentary time allows" Ministry of Justice.
Ministers have repeated the commitment in Parliament since. In April 2026 the government said it would accept the council's "two key recommendations", the PACCAR fix and proportionate regulation, and consider the rest later UK Parliament, written answer HL15862. In September 2026 the Ministry of Justice said it was "pursuing the earliest legislative vehicle" UK Parliament, answer 901382.
The November 9, 2026, answer adds two details. The fix will operate "with prospective effect", which is narrower than the retrospective and prospective reversal the council asked for, and the regulatory framework "is still being finalised" UK Parliament, written answer 39663. How agreements signed before a new Act will be treated depends on a bill that has not been published.
Self-regulation in the meantime
Until Parliament acts, the only funder-specific rulebook is voluntary. The Association of Litigation Funders describes itself as "charged by the Ministry of Justice with delivering self-regulation of litigation funding in England and Wales" Association of Litigation Funders.
Its code binds members only. The association says the code requires a funder to hold enough capital to cover its funding liabilities for at least 36 months, bars funders from taking control of the litigation or settlement talks, and allows withdrawal only in specific circumstances. A dispute over termination or settlement goes to an independent QC for a binding opinion Association of Litigation Funders.
What to ask before signing an English funding agreement
None of this is legal advice. A general counsel or law firm partner considering funding for a claim in England and Wales can put these questions to their own solicitors.
- Is the funder's return a multiple of its outlay, a percentage of the recovery, or a blend, and has that structure been tested against PACCAR and the 2025 Court of Appeal decision?
- If the agreement predates a reversal Act with prospective effect only, what happens to it?
- Is the funder a member of the Association of Litigation Funders, and does the agreement adopt its code?
- Who pays the other side's costs if the claim fails, and is after-the-event insurance in place?
For how US courts treat the same questions of disclosure and control, see our guides to disclosure rules and the funding agreement.
Sources
- UK Supreme Court, R (PACCAR Inc and others) v Competition Appeal Tribunal and others, UKSC/2021/0078, case page
Judgment date 26 July 2023 Neutral citation [2023] UKSC 28
- UK Supreme Court, press summary, R (PACCAR Inc) v Competition Appeal Tribunal [2023] UKSC 28
The Supreme Court allows the appeal by a majority.
- Ministry of Justice, press release on litigation funding legislation (published December 19, 2025)
clarifying that Litigation Funding Agreements are not Damages Based Agreements
- Ministry of Justice, Litigation Funding Agreements (Enforceability) Bill 2024 (March 20, 2024)
The Bill will extend and apply to England and Wales only.
- UK Parliament, bill record 3702, Litigation Funding Agreements (Enforceability) Bill [HL]
Litigation Funding Agreements (Enforceability) Bill [HL]
- Civil Justice Council, Review of Litigation Funding: Final Report (June 2, 2025)
which should be both retrospective and prospective in effect
- Judiciary of England and Wales, Civil Justice Council publishes Final Report on Litigation Funding (June 2, 2025)
has today published its Final Report on Litigation Funding
- UK Parliament, written question HL15862, answered April 7, 2026
We intend to legislate to implement these changes when parliamentary time allows.
- UK Parliament, question 901382, answered September 15, 2026 (API record)
We are pursuing the earliest legislative vehicle to deliver reforms that mitigate the effects of PACCAR
- UK Parliament, written question 39663, answered November 9, 2026 (API record)
mitigate the impact of the PACCAR judgment with prospective effect
- Court of Appeal, Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Ltd v Alex Neill Class Representative Ltd [2025] EWCA Civ 841
the CAT found that the revised LFAs were not DBAs so that the LFAs are enforceable
- Association of Litigation Funders of England and Wales, Code of Conduct
for a minimum period of 36 months
- Association of Litigation Funders of England and Wales, About us
charged by the Ministry of Justice with delivering self-regulation of litigation funding in England and Wales