Key points
- Under ABA Model Rule 1.2, a lawyer must abide by the client's decision whether to settle a matter.
- A liability insurer will ask you to sign a release promising not to file more claims for the accident.
- In a seven-state federal study, malpractice claims decided at trial paid medians at least two and a half times those that settled, but plaintiffs won only 23% of malpractice trials nationally.
- California law lists failing to attempt a prompt, fair settlement when liability is reasonably clear as an unfair claims practice.
Who decides
You do. The ABA's model rule on the lawyer-client relationship says a lawyer shall abide by a client's decision whether to settle a matter. ABA Model Rule 1.2 Your attorney can recommend, argue and warn, but cannot accept or reject an offer for you without your authority.
The same rules require your lawyer to give you what you need to decide. A lawyer must keep the client reasonably informed about the status of the matter and must explain it to the extent reasonably necessary for the client to make informed decisions. ABA Model Rule 1.4 States adopt their own versions of these rules, so the exact wording where you live may differ.
What signing ends
A settlement is a trade: money now for the end of the claim. The Texas Department of Insurance explains that when another driver's insurer offers a settlement for your injuries, the company will also ask you to sign a release promising that you will not file more claims for the accident. Texas Department of Insurance
That is why timing matters more than whether an offer is the first or the fifth. The department's advice is to talk to your doctor about any future medical treatment you might need before signing, and to use that information to judge whether the offer is fair. Texas Department of Insurance If you are still in treatment, the full cost of the injury may not be known yet.
If you disagree with the amount, the department says to tell the insurance company why. Texas Department of Insurance An offer is a position in a negotiation, and a counteroffer supported by records is an ordinary response.
What the research shows
No public dataset tracks first offers. The nearest evidence compares what claims paid at different stages, and the clearest example comes from medical malpractice, where insurers in some states must report closed claims.
In a Bureau of Justice Statistics study of seven states, payouts were typically lowest for claims closed before a lawsuit was filed and highest for claims closed after a trial. In Florida, Nevada and Texas, claims decided by trial paid medians at least two and a half times those that settled. BJS seven-state report
Holding out has a cost that the same body of research records. Plaintiffs won 23% of medical malpractice trials and 64% of motor vehicle trials in state courts in 2005. BJS full report Among motor vehicle plaintiffs who won, the median award was $15,000. BJS full report Time is the other cost: insurers in the seven-state study took an average of 26 to 29 months to close a malpractice claim. BJS seven-state report
These findings describe groups of cases, mostly from two decades ago. They show that later-stage resolutions tended to pay more in one type of claim and that trials are uncertain. They do not show what your first offer should be.
What the insurer is required to do
Insurers do not have a free hand. State laws on unfair claims practices set standards for how companies handle claims. California's statute, for example, lists as an unfair practice not attempting in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair and equitable settlements of claims in which liability has become reasonably clear. California Insurance Code 790.03
State insurance departments take complaints about claim handling. The Texas department accepts them in writing through an online portal, though it cautions that it cannot decide who was at fault or determine damage amounts. Texas Department of Insurance Your attorney can tell you what remedies your state allows.
Does a first settlement offer have to be the lowest?
Nothing in the public record shows that a first settlement offer is always the lowest, because no public dataset tracks first offers against final settlements. What federal data does show is narrower: in a Bureau of Justice Statistics study of medical malpractice claims in seven states, payouts were typically lowest for claims closed before a lawsuit was filed and highest for claims closed after trial, according to the BJS seven-state report.
A first offer can be reasonable, particularly when injuries are minor, treatment is finished and the insurance limits are low. Liability coverage has a dollar limit that is the most the insurer will pay. Texas Department of Insurance Ask your attorney whether the offer is near that limit.
When money pressure is driving the decision
Ethics rules recognize that financial strain can push people to settle. Minnesota's rule describes it directly: it allows a lawyer to guarantee a loan reasonably needed to help a client withstand delay in litigation that would otherwise put substantial pressure on the client to settle because of financial hardship and not on the merits. Minnesota Rule 1.8
If that describes your situation, say so to your attorney, and look at the other ways to get through the wait. The guide to covering your bills while you wait starts with benefits that are never repaid. The page on whether your lawyer can advance you money explains what the rules allow in different states.
Questions to ask your attorney
- Is my medical treatment far enough along to know the full cost of this injury?
- What are the policy limits, and how close is this offer to them?
- What would I net after fees, costs and liens if I accepted today?
- If we decline, what is the next step, how long would it take and what could go wrong?
- Exactly what would the release cover?
For the components behind any offer, see how much is my case worth.
Sources
- American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.2: Scope of Representation and Allocation of Authority Between Client and Lawyer
decision whether to settle a matter
- Texas Department of Insurance, Auto insurance guide
Before you sign the release, talk to your doctor about any future medical treatment you might need.
- American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.4: Communications
A lawyer shall explain a matter to the extent reasonably necessary to permit the client to make informed decisions regarding the representation.
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Medical Malpractice Insurance Claims in Seven States, 2000-2004 (full report text)
that were at least 21/2 times larger than claims that were
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Civil Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (full report text)
motor vehicle accident cases was $15,000
- California Insurance Code section 790.03 (California Legislative Information)
Not attempting in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair, and equitable settlements of claims in which liability has become reasonably clear.
- Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.8 (Office of the Revisor of Statutes)
a lawyer may guarantee a loan reasonably needed to enable the client to withstand delay in litigation