Who controls a funded case

The client controls a funded case under the bar's ethics rules and under what funders say their contracts provide, but a consent clause can change that. In the best-documented dispute, Sysco had taken about $140 million from Burford Capital, and an amendment to their agreement barred Sysco from accepting a settlement without the funder's prior written consent, according to a federal court order In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Feb. 2024 order.

By , Paralegal· Checked ·7 min read ·17 sources

Key points

  • ABA Model Rule 1.2(a) says a lawyer shall abide by a client's decision whether to settle a matter.
  • All seven commercial funders GAO interviewed said they made no decisions about litigation strategy.
  • Burford provided about $140 million to Sysco; an amendment required the funder's written consent to any settlement.
  • A Minnesota federal court refused on February 9, 2024 to substitute Burford's vehicle for Sysco, and was affirmed on June 3, 2024.

What the ethics rules say

The rules of professional conduct put the decision with the client. ABA Model Rule 1.2(a) says a lawyer shall abide by a client's decision whether to settle a matter ABA Model Rule 1.2. Model Rule 5.4(c) says a lawyer shall not permit a person who pays the lawyer to render legal services for another to direct or regulate the lawyer's professional judgment ABA Model Rule 5.4.

The ABA's 2020 Best Practices apply those rules to funding. The arrangement should be structured so that the client retains control of the litigation, and not the funder. In all cases the client and lawyer should have final say. A funder managing a party's litigation is described as a major red flag that should rarely, if ever, be allowed ABA Best Practices. The Best Practices are guidance and are not a basis for attorney discipline ABA Best Practices.

What ILFA members commit to

The International Legal Finance Association lists five best practices its members have committed to uphold: clarity, respecting duties to the courts, avoiding conflicts of interest, preserving confidentiality and privilege, and capital adequacy. Under the second, members should not interfere with the performance of lawyers' duties to the courts and to their clients ILFA.

None of the five addresses settlement consent by name. ILFA also opposes routine disclosure, arguing that the use of legal finance by a commercial client is a private matter ILFA. The commitments are a trade association's code, not a regulator's rule.

What funders say their agreements provide

Funders describe themselves as passive. All seven commercial funders GAO interviewed said they did not make any decisions about litigation strategy, and three said they had no authority to decide whether to settle GAO-23-105210, full report. Burford Capital says its agreements explicitly state that control of decision-making remains with the client, except in extraordinary circumstances agreed in advance Burford Capital, Introduction to legal finance. LexShares says settlement strategy and decisions remain in the plaintiff's control LexShares FAQ.

Burford's securities filing is more detailed. It says the company generally lacks contractual authority to veto a client's decision, but routinely consults on litigation strategy, helps choose arbitrators and experts, comments on draft pleadings and consults on potential settlement. It adds that on occasion it has specifically contracted to assume some control of a litigation matter Burford Capital 2025 Form 10-K.

Influence without a veto

Control is not only a matter of consent clauses. The New York City Bar's working group recorded the argument that control mechanisms may be subtle or indirect, including pressure over the decision to release additional funds at particular times New York City Bar report.

Economics also steer decisions. Where the funder's return is paid on a priority basis, certain settlement paths may become untenable, the working group noted New York City Bar report. One mediator told GAO that although patent owners controlled settlement decisions, it was clear the funders also had influence that sometimes complicated the discussions GAO-25-107214.

Burford and Sysco: how a consent clause played out

The facts below come from orders of the US District Court for the District of Minnesota in antitrust cases Sysco brought against pork and beef producers In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Feb. 2024 order.

  • Starting in 2019, Sysco financed its litigation with approximately $140 million from Burford.
  • An amendment to the funding agreement required Sysco not to accept a settlement without the capital providers' prior written consent, which was not to be unreasonably withheld.
  • In 2022 Sysco negotiated settlements with some defendants. Burford, thinking the amounts too low, withheld approval.
  • In December 2022 Burford obtained a temporary restraining order from an arbitration panel in New York to stop Sysco from finalizing the settlements.
  • Sysco fired its law firm, Boies Schiller Flexner, which also represented Burford on other matters.
  • On June 28, 2023, Sysco assigned its claims to Carina Ventures LLC, a vehicle created by Burford, and the two asked the court to substitute Carina as plaintiff.

These are the court's findings. The magistrate judge noted that the complete arbitration record is not public and that he worked from the redacted versions filed in federal court In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Feb. 2024 order.

What the courts did

On February 9, 2024, Magistrate Judge John Docherty denied the substitution. The central question, he wrote, was whether the court would allow a litigation funder to be substituted for its client in order to try to negotiate larger settlements, and the answer was no In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Feb. 2024 order.

District Judge John Tunheim affirmed on June 3, 2024, writing that Sysco and Burford's conduct was precisely the kind of conduct of which courts are wary In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, June 2024 order. In February 2025 the magistrate judge reported that a federal judge in Illinois had found a settlement agreement between Sysco and the defendant JBS existed, and recommended enforcing it in the Minnesota cases In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Feb. 2025 report.

How courts ask about control

Two federal disclosure rules target control directly. The District of New Jersey's Local Civil Rule 7.1.1 requires parties to state whether the funder's approval is necessary for litigation decisions or settlement decisions and, if so, the terms D.N.J. Local Civil Rule 7.1.1. Chief Judge Connolly's standing order in Delaware asks the same question in his cases In re Nimitz Technologies, Fed. Cir..

Elsewhere the question may never be asked. The Congressional Research Service found in 2018 that federal law imposed no systematic requirement that litigants divulge their financing arrangements to their adversaries CRS Legal Sidebar LSB10145, and GAO found no nationwide disclosure requirement in 2022 GAO-23-105210.

Can a litigation funder block a settlement?

A litigation funder can block a settlement only if the funding agreement gives it that right. Sysco's amended agreement with Burford Capital required the funder's prior written consent, and Burford withheld approval of settlements in 2022, according to a federal court order In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Feb. 2024 order. All seven commercial funders GAO interviewed said they made no decisions about litigation strategy GAO-23-105210, full report.

The ABA's Best Practices say control of key litigation decisions, including settlement, should remain with the client in all circumstances ABA Best Practices. Before signing, ask your attorney to identify every clause that requires the funder's notice, consultation or consent, and what happens if you and the funder disagree.

Sources

  1. U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Order denying substitution (Feb. 9, 2024) gave Burford the authority to approve or disapprove of settlements.
  2. American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.2 A lawyer shall abide by a client's decision whether to settle a matter.
  3. American Bar Association, Model Rule of Professional Conduct 5.4 A lawyer or law firm shall not share legal fees with a nonlawyer
  4. American Bar Association, Best Practices for Third-Party Litigation Funding (Resolution 111A, August 2020) This is a major red flag and should rarely, if ever, be allowed.
  5. International Legal Finance Association, About ILFA members should not interfere with the performance of lawyers’ duties to the courts and to their clients
  6. GAO-23-105210, full report (PDF) funders, and reported that they had a total of $12.4 billion in assets
  7. Burford Capital, Introduction to legal finance Burford’s minimum financing threshold is about $5 million needed by the client.
  8. LexShares, Frequently asked questions LexShares minimum investment amount is $200,000 and is uncapped regarding maximum funding size.
  9. Burford Capital Limited, Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2025 causing a reduction in our overall cumulative ROIC (83% ROIC)
  10. New York City Bar Association, Report to the President by the Working Group on Litigation Funding (2020) executed at the outset of the negotiations and before any non-public information is shared.
  11. U.S. Government Accountability Office, Intellectual Property: Information on Third-Party Funding of Patent Litigation (GAO-25-107214) two to three times their investment before the patent owner begins receiving
  12. U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Memorandum Opinion and Order affirming (June 3, 2024) Sysco and Burford’s conduct is precisely the kind of conduct of which
  13. U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Report and Recommendation (Feb. 13, 2025) has found a settlement agreement between JBS and Sysco existed
  14. U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, Local Civil Rule 7.1.1 Within 30 days of filing an initial pleading or transfer of the matter to this district
  15. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, In re Nimitz Technologies LLC, No. 2023-103 (Dec. 8, 2022) approval is necessary for litigation or settlement decisions
  16. Congressional Research Service, Following the Money: Should Federal Law Require Litigants to Disclose Litigation Funding Agreements? (LSB10145, May 31, 2018), as mirrored by EveryCRSReport federal law presently imposes no systematic requirement that litigants divulge their financing arrangements to their adversaries
  17. U.S. Government Accountability Office, Third-Party Litigation Financing: Market Characteristics, Data, and Trends (GAO-23-105210) This funding generally falls into two categories: commercial and consumer funding.

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options