What happens if the settlement is less than the advance?

If your settlement is too small to cover a non-recourse lawsuit loan, the funder gets whatever is left after higher-priority claims are paid, and you do not owe the difference. Vermont's statute says the consumer owes the company no money in excess of the net proceeds Vt. Stat. tit. 8, ch. 74. In one study of 38,318 completed cases, clients paid the funder nothing in 10% of them Avraham and Sebok, Cornell Law Review.

By , Paralegal· Checked ·7 min read ·10 sources

Key points

What non-recourse means in the statutes

A lawsuit loan, also called pre-settlement funding, is non-recourse when the funder can collect only from the case. The state laws that regulate funding write this into the definition of the product.

Illinois
If no proceeds are obtained from the claim, the consumer is not required to repay the funded amount or charges. the consumer is not required to repay the company the consumer legal funding amount or charges ilga.gov
Maine
If no proceeds in the civil claim or action are received, the consumer is not required to pay the company. If no proceeds in the civil claim or action are received, the consumer is not required to pay the company. legislature.maine.gov
Vermont
If the net proceeds are insufficient to repay the company, the consumer owes no money in excess of the net proceeds. the consumer shall owe the company no money in excess of the net proceeds legislature.vermont.gov
Missouri
The contract must state that you will not owe the company anything if there are no proceeds from your legal claim. YOU WILL NOT OWE (INSERT NAME OF THE CONSUMER LEGAL FUNDING COMPANY) ANYTHING IF THERE ARE NO PROCEEDS FROM YOUR LEGAL CLAIM revisor.mo.gov

Vermont's wording matters most for a small settlement, because it covers the case where there is some money but not enough. Our non-recourse funding guide explains the term in more depth. In a state with no funding statute, the same protection exists only if your contract says so.

Who is paid before the funder

The funder does not stand first in line. Several statutes set the order directly.

  • Illinois: liens related to the legal claim, including attorney's liens, Medicare and other statutory liens, take priority over any lien of the funding company 815 ILCS 121/40.
  • Nevada: an attorney's lien and a Medicare lien related to the claim take priority over a funder's lien Nev. Rev. Stat. ch. 604C.
  • Tennessee: any lien, subrogation interest or right of reimbursement against the claim takes priority over the funder's 2014 Tenn. Pub. Acts ch. 819.
  • Vermont: the funder is paid from net proceeds, defined as the recovery less attorney's fees, attorney liens, litigation costs, medical liens, reimbursement claims from health insurers and public plans, and workers' compensation liens Vt. Stat. tit. 8, ch. 74.

Put together, the usual order is the attorney's fee and case costs, then liens tied to the claim such as Medicare or a hospital lien, then the funder, then you. Who gets paid first covers the earlier steps.

What a shortfall looks like

A shortfall happens when the money left after fees, costs and liens is less than the funder's payoff. The funder takes what is left. It cannot bill you for the rest under the statutes above, and Vermont goes further by barring a funder from reporting you to a credit reporting agency when the net proceeds fall short Vt. Stat. tit. 8, ch. 74.

The harder truth is on the other side of the ledger. When the funder takes all that remains, you receive nothing from the settlement, even though you owe nothing more. The authors of the Cornell study listed this among the reasons clients in their data paid the funder $0: the money received from the defendant may have been insufficient to cover outstanding liens, including the attorney's own lien for costs Avraham and Sebok, Cornell Law Review.

How often funders collect less than they are owed

Reduced payoffs are common. Ronen Avraham and Anthony Sebok examined 38,318 completed cases from one large funder. In 10% the client paid nothing. In a little more than half of all transactions the client repaid the advance but paid a lower return than the contract called for Avraham and Sebok, Cornell Law Review.

The authors could not tell from the data why the funder accepted less. One explanation they offer is that the proceeds were smaller than the client and lawyer had anticipated, and the funder voluntarily agreed to forgo its right to full payment. That is a reason to have your attorney ask for a reduction when a settlement comes in low, before the funder's share consumes what would have been yours. See paying off a lawsuit loan.

What "you owe nothing" does not cover

The non-recourse promise has written exceptions, and they appear in the same capital-letter disclosures that make the promise.

  • Fraud. Illinois's required statement ends with the words "unless you or your attorney have committed fraud against the consumer legal funding company" 815 ILCS 121/30.
  • Breaking the contract. Missouri's version excepts cases where you or your attorney violated any material term of the contract, and says you can owe more than your recovery if you violated the contract Mo. Rev. Stat. 436.560.
  • False information. Nevada's version excepts a consumer who knowingly provided false information or committed fraud Nev. Rev. Stat. ch. 604C.

In plain terms, the protection covers a case that loses or pays too little. It does not cover dishonesty toward the funder, and in Missouri and Nevada it does not cover breaking a material term of the contract. Ask your attorney which terms your contract treats as material. The promise also does not turn the advance into something other than a debt in every state: Colorado's Supreme Court held that these advances are loans even though plaintiffs need not repay any deficiency Oasis v. Coffman, 2015 CO 63.

Do you have to pay back a lawsuit loan if you lose?

You do not have to pay back a non-recourse lawsuit loan if you lose your case. Illinois law says that if no proceeds are obtained from the legal claim, the consumer is not required to repay the funded amount or charges, and Maine and Vermont say the same in their own words 815 ILCS 121/5 Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 9-A, 12-102 Vt. Stat. tit. 8, ch. 74. The exceptions written into those laws are fraud and, in some states, a material breach of the contract.

What to ask before you sign and when you settle

  • Before signing, find the sentence that says what you owe if the proceeds fall short, and read the exceptions that follow it.
  • Ask your attorney for a rough estimate of fees, costs and liens, so you can see how much room is left for the funder and for you. The lawsuit loan cost calculator can help with the funder's share.
  • If the numbers leave you little or nothing, ask whether lien holders and the funder will reduce their claims. Whether to accept the settlement remains your decision, made with your attorney.

Sources

  1. Vermont Statutes, Title 8, Chapter 74, Consumer Litigation Funding Companies the consumer shall owe the company no money in excess of the net proceeds
  2. Ronen Avraham and Anthony Sebok, An Empirical Investigation of Third Party Consumer Litigant Funding, 104 Cornell Law Review 1133 (2019) Of the 38,318 cases completed in the dataset, in 10% of the cases the client paid nothing.
  3. Illinois Consumer Legal Funding Act, 815 ILCS 121/5, Definitions the consumer is not required to repay the company the consumer legal funding amount or charges
  4. Illinois Consumer Legal Funding Act, 815 ILCS 121/40, Assignability; liens shall take priority over any lien of the consumer legal funding company
  5. Nevada Revised Statutes, Chapter 604C, Consumer Litigation Funding takes priority over any lien imposed by a consumer litigation funding company
  6. Tennessee Litigation Financing Consumer Protection Act, 2014 Tenn. Pub. Acts ch. 819 shall take priority over any lien, subrogation interest or right of reimbursement of the litigation financier
  7. Illinois Consumer Legal Funding Act, 815 ILCS 121/30, Disclosures UNLESS YOU OR YOUR ATTORNEY HAVE COMMITTED FRAUD AGAINST THE CONSUMER LEGAL FUNDING COMPANY
  8. Missouri Revised Statutes section 436.560, Required disclosures UNLESS YOU OR YOUR ATTORNEY HAVE VIOLATED ANY MATERIAL TERM OF THIS CONTRACT
  9. Maine Revised Statutes, Title 9-A, section 12-102, Definitions If no proceeds in the civil claim or action are received, the consumer is not required to pay the company.
  10. Oasis Legal Finance Group, LLC v. Coffman, 2015 CO 63 (Colorado Supreme Court, Nov. 16, 2015) These transactions create debt, or an obligation to repay, that grows with the passage of time.

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options