Key points
- Miller UK v. Caterpillar (2014) kept work product protection for material shared under a confidentiality agreement and found attorney-client privilege waived.
- Acceleration Bay v. Activision (D. Del. 2018) ordered production of pre-funding communications, finding they were neither work product nor covered by common interest.
- In re Valsartan (D.N.J. 2019) held litigation funding irrelevant and not discoverable without good cause.
- A Delaware Superior Court rule adopted September 30, 2026 makes a funding agreement's existence and control rights discoverable, but not the agreement itself without cause.
Three separate questions
Discovery fights over funding turn on three questions that courts answer separately. The first is relevance: whether the funding agreement bears on any claim or defense. The second is work product: whether material prepared for or shared with a funder was prepared in anticipation of litigation, and whether sharing it waived protection. The third is attorney-client privilege: whether a funder falls within the common interest exception that prevents waiver.
A funded party can win on one and lose on another, and the same document set often produces a split ruling. The decisions below are cited to the opinions themselves.
Leading decisions at a glance
| Decision | Court and year | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Miller UK v. Caterpillar | N.D. Ill. 2014 | Deal documents irrelevant; work product kept where confidentiality agreed; privilege waived |
| Lambeth v. Seagate | W.D. Pa. 2018 | Funder communications and agreement protected as work product |
| Carlyle v. Moonmouth | Del. Ch. 2015 | Funding documents protected as work product |
| In re International Oil Trading | Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2016 | Common interest and work product apply; redacted agreement produced |
| In re Valsartan | D.N.J. 2019 | Funding irrelevant; no discovery without good cause |
| Leader Technologies v. Facebook | D. Del. 2010 | No common interest with prospective funders; production ordered |
| Acceleration Bay v. Activision | D. Del. 2018 | Pre-funding communications not work product; production ordered |
| Burkhart v. Genworth | Del. Ch. 2024 | Unredacted funding agreement ordered produced in a class action |
Decisions protecting funder communications
Work product is the stronger shield because it is not waived by every disclosure to a third party, only by disclosure that makes it likely an adversary will see the material. In Miller UK the court noted that the plaintiff had taken precautions through confidentiality agreements with at least some prospective funders, and it preserved protection for what those funders received. Material given to funders with no such agreement lost protection.
Lambeth went further. The court found that communications with funders were primarily, perhaps exclusively, for the purpose of preparing for litigation and that all of the materials were shielded as work product. In Carlyle the Delaware Court of Chancery reached the same result under Delaware law and observed that in the funding context the choice of legal test may be outcome-determinative.
International Oil Trading is the leading decision extending attorney-client privilege. The bankruptcy court held that communications with Burford were protected by both the common interest exception and the agency exception. It still ordered the funding agreement produced with payment terms redacted.
Decisions ordering disclosure
The District of Delaware has been less receptive. In Leader Technologies the court upheld an order to produce documents shared with litigation financing companies, finding no common interest privilege with funders that never closed a deal. In Acceleration Bay, communications sent to a funder during negotiations, before any agreement or lawsuit, were held not to be work product because their primary purpose was to obtain a loan. The court also found no common legal interest and held the communications relevant.
Class actions raise a separate concern. In Burkhart v. Genworth the Court of Chancery ordered complete and unredacted copies of the funding agreement delivered to the defendants. It found the agreement relevant because of the class action context and, after reviewing it in private, found that it reflected no opinion work product.
Courts may also ask for themselves. The Federal Circuit declined in In re Nimitz Technologies to block a Delaware judge's order requiring funding-related documents for the court's own inspection, and in Backertop Licensing v. Canary Connect it affirmed related orders in a precedential 2024 opinion. In re Nimitz Backertop
When relevance ends the inquiry
Many disputes stop at relevance. In re Valsartan held that litigation funding is irrelevant to the claims and defenses and therefore not discoverable, and that the court would order discovery only on a showing of good cause, for example that a nonparty is making the litigation or settlement decisions. Miller UK reached a similar view of the deal documents.
Delaware's Superior Court wrote that approach into a rule in 2026. An order dated September 30, 2026 added Civil Rule 26(b)(3): a party may learn that a funding agreement exists, who the parties are and whether the funder has control rights, and the court may order production of the control provisions for cause. The agreement is not admissible at trial. Delaware Superior Court order
Does sharing documents with a litigation funder waive privilege?
Sharing documents with a litigation funder can waive attorney-client privilege, and courts are divided on when. Miller UK v. Caterpillar (N.D. Ill. 2014) held privilege waived because a funder's interest in a successful outcome is not a common legal interest, while In re International Oil Trading (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2016) held funder communications protected by the common interest exception.
Work product protection is more often preserved, especially where a confidentiality agreement was signed before anything was shared. The ABA's Best Practices advise lawyers to assume a court or the other party may examine the funding arrangement at some point. ABA Resolution 111A
What the cases suggest in practice
The facts that decided these cases repeat. Counsel advising on a funded matter can use them as a checklist of questions, without treating any one decision as the rule in another court.
- Was a confidentiality agreement signed with each funder before material was shared (Miller UK).
- Were the documents created for the litigation or to obtain financing (Acceleration Bay, Lambeth).
- Which work product test does the forum apply (Carlyle).
- Does the agreement give the funder control over litigation or settlement decisions (Valsartan, Delaware Rule 26(b)(3)).
- Is the case a class action, where the court reviews adequacy of representation (Burkhart).
Fee-sharing and independence rules that bear on the same agreements are covered in ABA guidance, Rule 5.4 and fee sharing, and court disclosure rules in disclosure rules by court and state.
Sources
- Miller UK Ltd. v. Caterpillar, Inc., 17 F. Supp. 3d 711 (N.D. Ill. 2014) (GovInfo)
To avoid the risk of disclosure, Miller took precautions through confidentiality agreements with at least some prospective funders.
- Lambeth Magnetic Structures, LLC v. Seagate Technology (US) Holdings, Inc. (W.D. Pa. 2018) (GovInfo)
these communications were primarily, perhaps exclusively, for the purpose of preparing for litigation
- Carlyle Investment Management L.L.C. v. Moonmouth Co. S.A. (Del. Ch. Feb. 24, 2015) (Justia copy)
In the context of litigation funding, the choice of test may be outcome-determinative.
- In re International Oil Trading Co., LLC, 548 B.R. 825 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2016) (GovInfo)
the Burford Communications are protected by both the common interest exception and the agency exception
- In re Valsartan NDMA Contamination Products Liability Litigation, 405 F. Supp. 3d 612 (D.N.J. 2019) (GovInfo)
The Court finds that litigation funding is irrelevant to the claims and defenses in the case and, therefore, plaintiffs’ litigation funding is not discoverable.
- Leader Technologies, Inc. v. Facebook, Inc., 719 F. Supp. 2d 373 (D. Del. 2010) (Caselaw Access Project)
The Court concludes that Judge Stark did not commit clear error in finding the common interest privilege inapplicable and ordering production of documents withheld by Leader as privileged.
- Acceleration Bay LLC v. Activision Blizzard, Inc. (D. Del. Feb. 9, 2018) (GovInfo)
For that reason alone, the communications are not work product.
- Burkhart v. Genworth Financial, Inc. (Del. Ch. Aug. 21, 2024) (Delaware Courts)
Plaintiffs shall deliver complete and fully unredacted copies of the Funding Agreement and the Contingent Fee Agreements to Defendants within seven days.
- In re Nimitz Technologies LLC, No. 2023-103 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 8, 2022)
Nor has Nimitz shown a clear right to preclude in camera inspection under these circumstances.
- Backertop Licensing LLC v. Canary Connect, Inc., No. 23-2367 (Fed. Cir. July 16, 2024)
confirming that the District Court has inherent authority to seek information
- Superior Court of Delaware, Order Amending Civil Rule 26(b) (Sept. 30, 2026)
A litigation-funding agreement is not admissible at trial.
- ABA House of Delegates Resolution 111A, Best Practices for Third-Party Litigation Funding (Aug. 2020)
The careful lawyer should assume that the litigation funding arrangement may well be examined by a court or the other party at some point in litigation.