Key points
- Aon describes two core US products: defense-side adverse judgment insurance and plaintiff-side judgment preservation insurance.
- Marsh says contingent risk insurance sets a floor on recoveries for plaintiffs or a ceiling on exposure for defendants.
- The number of judgment preservation policies sold is unknown because the deals are private and no regulation requires disclosure, Carrier Management reported in 2024.
- Aon's February 2022 brochure put its insurer panel at more than two dozen carriers with capacity for up to $1 billion of coverage on a single risk.
The main covers at a glance
Brokers group these products under two labels, litigation risk insurance and contingent risk insurance. Aon calls litigation risk insurance a tool to protect businesses from catastrophic judgments and to preserve favorable ones Aon brochure. Marsh uses the label contingent risk insurance for the transfer of known legal exposures to insurers Marsh.
| Cover | Who buys it | What it pays for |
|---|---|---|
| After-the-event (ATE) | A party to a dispute, usually the claimant | The opponent's legal costs if the insured loses, plus own disbursements |
| Judgment preservation (JPI) | A plaintiff holding a judgment or award | Loss if the judgment is reversed or cut on appeal |
| Adverse judgment (AJI) | A defendant, or a buyer in an M&A deal | A final judgment above an agreed retention |
After-the-event insurance
After-the-event insurance is bought once a dispute has arisen. Its principal function, in the words of the Jackson review of civil litigation costs in England and Wales, is to give the insured a fund to meet the opponent's costs if the insured is ordered to pay them. The review found that in most cases the claimant is the party who takes out the policy Jackson final report.
ATE belongs to legal systems where the loser pays. Aon places it in what it calls costs-shifting jurisdictions and in arbitrations Aon. In England and Wales, section 46 of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 bars a costs order from including the premium of a costs insurance policy, with a narrow exception for expert reports in clinical negligence claims legislation.gov.uk.
Judgment preservation insurance
Judgment preservation insurance pays the insured a portion of a judgment if it is overturned on appeal ABA Journal. Aon says the cover lets a winning party lock in some or all of the award while the appeal is pending Aon brochure. Policies pay only once a later judgment cutting the award becomes final Aon JPI brochure.
The product's best-known claim came in 2024. A federal appeals court reversed a $1.6 billion judgment that BMC Software had won against IBM, leaving the insurers that had guaranteed part of the award on the hook for millions of dollars, the ABA Journal reported, citing Bloomberg Law ABA Journal. A group of carriers led by Liberty Mutual had written the cover Carrier Management.
Adverse judgment insurance
Adverse judgment insurance is the defense-side counterpart. Aon says its policies cover final judgments in ongoing litigation, but not defense costs or settlements, and do not require the insurers to take control of the case. The likely worst-case damages figure typically serves as the point at which coverage attaches Aon brochure.
The main use is in mergers and acquisitions, where a lawsuit against the target can stall a sale. In one Aon case study, a buyer demanded a $600 million escrow against a class action, and the target instead bought $520 million of cover above a $100 million retention Aon brochure. Pricing and exclusions are covered under contingent risk insurance.
Who sells litigation insurance?
Litigation insurance is sold through specialist teams at insurance brokers, who place each risk with a group of insurers. Aon, Marsh and Vanbridge all publish descriptions of the product, and Aon's February 2022 brochure said it marketed submissions to more than two dozen insurers rated A or better, with combined capacity of up to $1 billion Aon JPI brochure.
Large risks are shared. A senior vice president at the broker HUB International told Carrier Management in 2024 that roughly 30 to 40 insurers, some writing through managing general agents, take part in the layered programs behind big judgment preservation policies Carrier Management.
How big is the litigation insurance market?
No public dataset measures the litigation insurance market. The number of judgment preservation policies sold is unknown, because the deals between buyer, broker and insurer are private and no regulation requires disclosure, Carrier Management reported in July 2024 Carrier Management.
- Largest reported claim
- Carrier Management, citing Bloomberg Law, put BMC's judgment preservation coverage at between $500 million and $750 million.
BMC’s insurance coverage provides between $500 million and $750 million
carriermanagement.com - Early loss record
- Aon says carrier loss ratios stayed in the low single digits from 2015 to 2021, when most policies were tied to M&A deals.
carrier loss ratios remained in the low single digits
assets.aon.com - Aon's portfolio since 2014
- 8.1% of the policies Aon placed led to a carrier paying a loss, each for the full limit and each on a judgment preservation deal.
The remaining 91.9% of Aon’s bound deals, comprised in large part of adverse judgment insurance policies, have yielded no losses to date.
aon.com - Appetite now
- Aon reports that the judgment preservation losses reduced insurers' appetite across the wider contingent risk market.
have indeed led to a reduction in carrier appetite
aon.com
How insurance and litigation funding fit together
Insurance and litigation finance are increasingly combined. Aon says a judgment preservation policy can serve as collateral for a loan, and that such loans are cheaper because the lender is repaid from insurance proceeds if the appeal is lost Aon JPI brochure.
Funders and law firms buy cover too. Vanbridge lists principal protection insurance for capital that litigation funders have committed to a case or portfolio Vanbridge. Marsh offers work-in-progress cover for contingency-fee firms, which it says is available for up to 90% of fees and 100% of costs invested in a portfolio of cases Marsh. For the funding side, see how litigation finance works and portfolio funding.
Questions to put to a broker and outside counsel
Whether a policy is worth its premium is a decision for the company and its advisers. Vanbridge says premiums generally range from 8% to 20% of the limit, usually as a single payment Vanbridge.
- Which event triggers payment, and must every appeal be exhausted first?
- Where does coverage attach, and how much of the loss stays with the insured?
- Does the policy respond to a settlement, or only to a final judgment?
- Can the premium be financed, and at what cost?
Sources
- Aon, Global Claims Study 2026
just 8.1% of policies placed have resulted in carriers paying a loss (each was a limit loss), with all of those instances occurring on JPI deals
- Aon, Litigation Risk Insurance Solutions (brochure)
Litigation risk insurance is a strategic tool to help protect businesses from the risks of catastrophic judgments and preserve the benefits of favorable judgments.
- Aon, Judgment Preservation Insurance: Protecting and Monetizing Court Judgments and Arbitration Awards (February 2022)
who between them have the market capacity to provide up to $1 billion in coverage
- Aon, Litigation and Contingent Risks Insurance
protects against the risk of having to pay the other side’s legal costs, the party’s own disbursements and part of their own legal fees
- Aon, 2025 Transaction Solutions Global Claims Study: North America
These reported anticipated losses have led to a reduction in carrier appetite, not only in judgment preservation insurance, but also in the broader contingent risk market
- Marsh, Contingent Liability Insurance
setting a floor on recoveries for plaintiffs or a ceiling on exposure for defendants
- Vanbridge, Contingent Liability Insurance
Premiums generally range from 8-20% rate-on-line
- Carrier Management, Judgment Day (July 8, 2024)
The number of JPI policies sold is unknown, as the dealings between the buyer, broker and insurance companies are private and there are no regulations requiring disclosure.
- ABA Journal, As judgment preservation insurance gains steam, appellate decision leaves insurers 'on the hook' for millions (May 8, 2024)
The insurance pays the insured a portion of a judgment if it is overturned on appeal.
- Lord Justice Jackson, Review of Civil Litigation Costs: Final Report (December 2009)
is to provide the insured with a fund to meet the opponent’s costs in the event that the insured is ordered to pay those costs
- Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, section 46 (legislation.gov.uk)
A costs order made in favour of a party to proceedings who has taken out a costs insurance policy may not include provision requiring the payment of an amount