Key points
- Section 4 of the Clayton Act lets an injured business recover threefold damages, costs and a reasonable attorney's fee.
- A Minnesota federal court found Sysco financed its litigation with approximately $140 million from Burford starting in 2019.
- The court refused in February 2024 to substitute Burford's special purpose vehicle for Sysco, and the district judge affirmed in June 2024.
- The judge who affirmed noted that the magistrate judge did not invalidate the assignment of Sysco's claims; he denied substitution.
Why antitrust claims attract funding
The first reason is the remedy. Any person injured in its business or property by an antitrust violation may sue in federal court and recover three times its damages, plus the cost of suit and a reasonable attorney's fee 15 U.S.C. § 15. A funder's return is paid from the recovery, so a statutory multiplier and fee-shifting both enlarge the pool from which it is paid.
The second is cost. Burford describes antitrust claims as among the most complex, expensive and high-stakes commercial claims because they require highly specialized lawyers and expert witnesses Burford Capital. Antitrust was among the claim types that the seven commercial funders GAO interviewed said they finance GAO-23-105210.
The third is the kind of plaintiff. Some large purchasers sue in their own name instead of staying in a class. The Minnesota court described Sysco as a large food distributor and a direct-action plaintiff, and its claims were consolidated into multidistrict proceedings alongside others In re Pork Antitrust Litigation. A direct-action plaintiff controls its own claim and can contract with a funder in a way an absent class member cannot. Funding of class cases is covered in class action funding.
What funders offer antitrust plaintiffs
Burford lists three uses on its antitrust page: managing expert and expense costs while keeping the law firm of choice, advancing a portion of a pending antitrust claim or unenforced judgment to generate immediate cash, and building antitrust portfolios Burford Capital. The second of these is claim monetization.
Published pricing for antitrust funding does not exist. Deal terms are negotiated case by case, and the general structures are described in cost and returns.
What happened between Sysco and Burford?
Sysco and Burford fell out over settlement authority: a February 9, 2024 order in the District of Minnesota records that the litigation finance contract gave Burford the authority to approve or disapprove of settlements, and that Burford refused to permit settlements Sysco had tried to reach with some defendants In re Pork Antitrust Litigation. A later report in the same case says the contract had been amended to give Burford that authority.
The same order sets out what followed. Sysco fired its counsel, Boies Schiller Flexner, which also acted for Burford on other matters. The dispute produced an arbitration in New York, court actions in New York and Illinois, and a partial stay of two multidistrict proceedings while Sysco hired new lawyers In re Pork Antitrust Litigation.
Sysco and Burford then settled their differences by assigning Sysco's antitrust claims to Carina Ventures LLC, a special purpose vehicle Burford established in June 2023 that, the court said, apparently had no assets other than the claims In re Pork Antitrust Litigation.
- Amount
- Sysco financed its litigation with approximately $140 million from Burford, starting in 2019.
$140 million of litigation financing provided by Burford.
govinfo.gov - Settlement authority
- The contract gave Burford authority to approve or disapprove settlements.
gave Burford the authority to approve or disapprove of settlements.
govinfo.gov - Substitution
- The magistrate judge denied the motions to substitute Carina for Sysco on February 9, 2024.
motions for substitution are denied.
govinfo.gov - On review
- The district judge affirmed on June 3, 2024, noting that the assignment itself was not invalidated.
invalidate Sysco’s assignment of its claims to Carina, but denied the motions for
govinfo.gov
What the court decided
Carina and Sysco asked the Minnesota court to substitute Carina as plaintiff under Rule 25(c). The magistrate judge refused. He wrote that the transfer had caused serious practical problems in the litigation and would allow a financer with no interest beyond maximizing profit on its investment to override decisions made by the party that brought suit In re Pork Antitrust Litigation.
The district judge affirmed on June 3, 2024, finding the decision not clearly erroneous. His opinion records that the magistrate judge did not invalidate Sysco's assignment of its claims to Carina. He denied substitution after reasoning that it would be contrary to the Federal Rules and to public policy favoring party control over litigation and settlement Memorandum Opinion and Order.
The consequences continued. A February 2025 report and recommendation in the same litigation addressed whether settlement agreements that Sysco negotiated with the JBS defendants, before Burford obtained an arbitral injunction, could be enforced Report and Recommendation. Substitution under Rule 25(c) is discretionary, and the Minnesota orders bind only those cases. The order notes that a substitution motion was also filed in the broiler chicken litigation in the Northern District of Illinois; that court's ruling is not among the sources reviewed for this page.
Can an antitrust claim be assigned to a funder?
An antitrust claim can be assigned, and the Minnesota court did not hold otherwise: the district judge's June 2024 opinion states that the magistrate judge did not invalidate Sysco's assignment of its claims to Carina but denied the motion to substitute Carina as plaintiff Memorandum Opinion and Order. Ownership of a claim and the right to appear as the named party were treated as separate questions.
Assignment is also contested outside the United States. Burford tells investors it expects further supreme court guidance in Europe during 2026 on the permissible use of assignment models in complex antitrust and cartel damages litigation Burford Capital 2025 Form 10-K. A company considering a sale or assignment of an antitrust claim should ask counsel how the court where the case is pending has treated substitution and whether co-plaintiffs or defendants can object.
Terms to settle before taking antitrust funding
- Who decides whether to accept a settlement offer, and does any amendment or side letter change that?
- If the company wants to settle for commercial reasons, such as preserving a supplier relationship, what does it owe the funder?
- Does the company's litigation counsel also act for the funder in other matters?
- How are disputes with the funder resolved, and can an arbitrator enjoin a settlement?
- Does the court require disclosure of the funding? See who controls the case and the funding agreement.
Sources
- 15 U.S.C. § 15 (Clayton Act section 4), U.S. Code 2024 edition, via GovInfo
and shall recover threefold the damages by him
- U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Order denying substitution (Feb. 9, 2024)
$140 million of litigation financing provided by Burford.
- Burford Capital, Antitrust and competition
Advance a portion of a pending antitrust claim or unenforced award or judgment to generate immediate cash
- U.S. Government Accountability Office, Third-Party Litigation Financing: Market Characteristics, Data, and Trends (GAO-23-105210), full report (PDF)
including intellectual property, antitrust, asset recovery, fraud, and
- U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Memorandum Opinion and Order affirming (June 3, 2024)
invalidate Sysco’s assignment of its claims to Carina, but denied the motions for
- U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, Report and Recommendation (Feb. 13, 2025)
The Court denied the substitution motions.
- Burford Capital Limited, Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2025
permissible use of assignment models in complex antitrust and cartel damages litigation