Average personal injury settlement: what the data shows

No public dataset records personal injury settlements. The best federal data covers trials: half of the plaintiffs who won a tort trial in state courts in 2005 were awarded $24,000 or less, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics. The median ranged from $15,000 in car accident trials to $400,000 in medical malpractice trials, and a few very large awards pulled the average far above the median.

By , Paralegal· Checked ·5 min read ·6 sources

Key points

  • Half of winning plaintiffs in 2005 tort trials were awarded $24,000 or less.
  • Median awards ranged from $15,000 in car accident trials to $400,000 in medical malpractice trials.
  • Total tort awards of $3.6 billion across 8,763 winning plaintiffs work out to a mean of about $410,000, roughly 17 times the median.
  • Plaintiffs won 51.6% of tort trials overall, and trials were an estimated 4% of tort dispositions.

Median trial awards by case type

The Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) surveyed tort trials that ended in state courts in 2005. A tort case is a claim for harm caused by someone's wrongful act, which covers most personal injury claims. The table shows the median award to plaintiffs who won and how often plaintiffs won.

Case typeMedian awardPlaintiffs won
Car accident $15,00064.3%
Animal attack $21,00075.2%
Intentional tort $38,00051.6%
Premises liability $98,00038.4%
Medical malpractice $400,00022.7%
Product liability, not asbestos $500,00019.6%
All tort trials $24,00051.6%
Median final awards to winning plaintiffs and plaintiff win rates in state court tort trials, 2005. Source: Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005, tables 4 and 5.

The figures are in the BJS tort trial tables. Notice the pattern: the case types with the highest medians are the ones plaintiffs most often lose. Car accident cases made up about 70% of the trials that plaintiffs won, which is why the overall median sits close to the car accident figure. BJS full report

The gap between the mean and the median

A median is the middle value: half of the awards are below it and half above. A mean, the ordinary average, adds up every award and divides by the number of winners. In injury cases the two are far apart.

BJS reports that plaintiffs who won tort trials in 2005 were awarded an estimated $3.6 billion in total, and it counts 8,763 tort trials with plaintiff winners. BJS full report Dividing one by the other gives a mean of about $410,000. That is our arithmetic from the two published figures, and it is roughly 17 times the $24,000 median.

The spread explains the gap. Among tort plaintiffs who won, 32.7% were awarded under $10,000 and 5.0% were awarded more than $1 million. BJS civil trial tables A handful of very large verdicts carry the mean, while the median describes what the typical winner saw.

This is why two websites can both cite real data and give very different averages. Before trusting a figure, check whether it is a mean or a median.

What insurers report

Most injury claims are paid by an insurance company without a trial, and insurers publish a few averages for car crashes. The average auto liability claim for bodily injury was $28,278 in 2024, a figure that includes the insurer's claim handling costs. Insurance Information Institute

The Insurance Research Council, working from 7.4 million claims at nine insurers, found that average bodily injury claim payments rose from about $14,000 in 2017 to more than $20,000 in 2022. Insurance Research Council Both figures are means, and both cover car crashes only. No comparable public series exists for falls, malpractice or other injury claims as a group.

Why trial data is not settlement data

Trials accounted for an estimated 4% of tort dispositions in state courts in 2005. Bureau of Justice Statistics The cases that reach a verdict are the ones where the two sides could not agree, so they are not a fair sample of all claims.

The data is also old. The 2005 survey is the latest national one in the BJS series that we found, and its dollar figures have not been adjusted for inflation here. In the 75 most populous counties, the median tort award was $31,000 in 2005 against $38,000 in 1996, a change BJS says was not statistically significant. BJS tort trial tables

A verdict is also not always the amount paid. Awards were reduced for the plaintiff's own negligence in 15% of tort trials that plaintiffs won, and post-trial motions were filed in nearly one in three tort trials. BJS full report

What is the average personal injury settlement?

No public average for personal injury settlements exists, because settlements are private and no court or agency collects them. The nearest federal figure is the $24,000 median award to plaintiffs who won tort trials in state courts in 2005, reported by the Bureau of Justice Statistics, with medians by case type that ran from $15,000 for car accidents to $400,000 for medical malpractice.

Those numbers describe trial winners two decades ago. They are a reference point, not a forecast for any one claim.

What decides the value of your case

The table above shows that the type of case matters more than any overall average. Within a case type, value turns on your medical bills, your lost income, how the injury changes your life, your share of fault and the insurance available to pay. The page on how much a case is worth explains each part.

More detail by case type is on the pages for the average car accident settlement, the average slip and fall settlement and the average dog bite claim.

Questions to ask your attorney

  • What have cases like mine resolved for in this county, and what is that based on?
  • What are the limits of every insurance policy that could pay?
  • How much of a settlement would go to fees, case costs and medical liens?
  • How long is the case likely to take, and what would change that?

If the wait is the problem, the guide to covering bills while you wait lists options and their costs.

Sources

  1. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (full report text) Half of plaintiff winners in tort trials were awarded $24,000 or less in damages
  2. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (NCJ 228129), tables Premises liability 666 98,000 608 100,000 44 65,000
  3. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Civil Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (NCJ 223851), tables Tort cases 8,455 $24,000 32.7% 30.6% 21.3% 10.4% 5.0%
  4. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005, summary page Together, bench and jury trials accounted for an estimated 4% of all tort dispositions in 2005.
  5. Insurance Information Institute, Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance (ISO data) the average auto liability claim for bodily injury was $28,278
  6. Insurance Research Council, news release on Auto Injury Insurance Claims: A Study of Increasing Claim Severity (July 30, 2026) from approximately $14,000 in 2017 to more than $20,000 in 2022

See which companies fund cases like yours, with their published rates.

Check your options