Key points
- The median award to winning plaintiffs in premises liability trials was $98,000 in 2005.
- Plaintiffs won 38.4% of premises liability trials, compared with 64.3% of car accident trials.
- Awards were reduced for the plaintiff's own negligence in 41% of premises liability trials that plaintiffs won, by about half on average.
- Homeowners insurers paid an average of $42,452 per liability claim for bodily injury and property damage from 2020 to 2024.
The numbers that exist
The Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) surveyed tort trials that ended in state courts in 2005. It does not report slip and fall cases separately. It reports premises liability, which it defines as injury or death caused by a dangerous condition of residential or commercial property. BJS full report
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Median award to winning plaintiffs | $98,000 | BJS, 2005 trials |
| Share of trials plaintiffs won | 38.4% | BJS, 2005 trials |
| Winners whose award was cut for own fault | 41.1% | BJS, 2005 trials |
| Median time from filing to verdict | 24.5 months | BJS, 2005 trials |
| Average homeowners liability claim, injury and damage | $42,452 | Triple-I, 2020 to 2024 |
The trial figures are in the BJS tort trial tables. The insurance figure is from the Insurance Information Institute.
Why the $98,000 median misleads
The median counts winners only. Plaintiffs lost about 62% of premises liability trials in 2005, and a loss at trial pays nothing. BJS tort trial tables An average across everyone who went to trial would be far lower than $98,000.
The winners' awards were also spread widely. About 37% of them received $50,000 or less, and about 7% received more than $1 million.
| Final award | Share of winning plaintiffs |
|---|---|
| Under $10,000 | 5.6% |
| $10,001 to $50,000 | 30.9% |
| $50,001 to $250,000 | 32.9% |
| $250,001 to $1 million | 23.3% |
| Over $1 million | 7.4% |
Those shares come from the BJS civil trial tables. The cases behind them are not typical claims. Trials accounted for an estimated 4% of tort dispositions in 2005, and the number of premises liability trials in the largest counties fell 52% between 1996 and 2005. BJS summary BJS full report
Your share of the blame can cut the award
The injured person's own conduct was an issue in fall cases more often than in any other case type. In two-fifths of the premises liability trials that plaintiffs won in 2005, the award was reduced because of the plaintiff's own negligence, and the average reduction was about 51%. BJS full report
Across all tort trials, awards were reduced in 15% of cases. BJS tort trial tables How fault is shared depends on state law, so ask your attorney how your state treats a plaintiff who is partly responsible.
Who pays these claims
In premises liability trials in 2005, 62.7% of the pairings were an individual suing a business, 21.4% were an individual suing another individual, and 12.1% were an individual suing a government body. BJS tort trial tables
A fall at someone's home may be covered by the owner's homeowners insurance. From 2020 to 2024, homeowners insurers paid an average of $42,452 per liability claim for bodily injury and property damage, and $13,921 per claim under medical payments and similar coverage. Insurance Information Institute These averages cover every kind of liability claim on a home policy, not falls alone, and they are insurer-side figures that include small and large claims together.
Liability claims on home policies are uncommon. Insurers recorded 0.09 liability claims per 100 insured homes a year in that period, against 5.48 property damage claims. Insurance Information Institute
What is the average slip and fall settlement?
No public average for slip and fall settlements exists, because settlements are private agreements that no court or agency collects. The nearest federal figure is the $98,000 median award in premises liability trials that plaintiffs won in state courts in 2005, reported by the Bureau of Justice Statistics, and plaintiffs won only 38.4% of those trials.
The figure is two decades old and has not been adjusted for inflation here. Treat any single number you see online with the same caution, and ask where it came from.
What decides the value of your claim
The data points to three things. The first is whether the owner can be held responsible at all, since most plaintiffs who went to trial lost. The second is your own share of fault. The third is the size of your losses: medical bills, lost income and lasting harm. The page on how much a case is worth walks through each part.
Time matters as well. Half of premises liability cases that went to trial took 24.5 months or more from filing to verdict. BJS tort trial tables
Questions to ask your attorney
- What do we have to prove about the property owner, and what evidence do we have so far?
- How does this state treat a plaintiff who is partly at fault?
- Which insurance policy would pay, and what is its limit?
- What have similar fall cases resolved for in this county, and how do you know?
If the wait is the hard part, the guide to covering bills while you wait lists options and costs, and average personal injury settlement compares trial data across case types.
Sources
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (NCJ 228129), tables
Premises liability 666 98,000 608 100,000 44 65,000
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (full report text)
Half of plaintiff winners in tort trials were awarded $24,000 or less in damages
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Civil Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005 (NCJ 223851), tables
Tort cases 8,455 $24,000 32.7% 30.6% 21.3% 10.4% 5.0%
- Bureau of Justice Statistics, Tort Bench and Jury Trials in State Courts, 2005, summary page
Together, bench and jury trials accounted for an estimated 4% of all tort dispositions in 2005.
- Insurance Information Institute, Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (Verisk data)
Bodily injury and property damage 0.06 42,452 Medical payments and other 0.02 13,921